Who is stronger, Ma Chao or Zhao Yun? Most of the heroes in Romance of the Three Kingdoms are impressive. Ma Chao and Zhao Yun are both superheroes in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms. They have many similarities, and it is inevitable that people will always compare them. Next, let's see who is stronger.

Who is stronger, Ma Chao or Zhao Yun? 1 1. Who is stronger, Zhao Yun or Ma Chao?

In Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Ma Chao and Zhao Yun are both five generals in Shu and Han Dynasties, and they are both trump cards in Liu Bei's hands. Ma Chao once killed Cao Cao, cut his beard and abandoned his robe, and lamented that "the horse didn't die, but I came to a bad end." This shows what damage Ma Chao has done to Cao Cao.

Zhao Yun is also very good. The battle of Changbanpo was a god, which made Cao Cao exclaim: How is this Zhao Yun better than Lu Bu? No, I have to live. As a result, Cao Cao's love flooded, but he gave Zhao Yun a chance. Although pregnant with sinus, he rode alone against thousands of troops, but he finally escaped by luck.

The reason given in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is that A Dou is the real dragon emperor, so he protected Zhao Yun and could fly out even if he fell into a horse pit, but who actually protected whom? Otherwise, why did Liu Bei throw the child? Therefore, Zhao Yun was called "God of War" by later generations.

But the only pity is that Ma Chao and Zhao Yun didn't fight one-on-one in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Therefore, deciding who is the better of the two is like a muddled account. There are also two ways to rank the top 24 of the three countries. One is: one Lu, two Zhao, three Dian Wei, and Zhao Yun comes second. There is another one: one Lu, two horses, three Dian Wei, and Ma Chao is the second.

So just look at the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Who should come second, Zhao Yun or Ma Chao? I think we should choose Zhao Yun. The evidence is that Ma Chao surrendered to Liu Bei after hitting Zhang Fei. At this time, the two men clashed. Let's look at the original text first.

Suddenly, Shu Jiang and Mahan led the troops. Zhao Yun said, "I am willing to take these two alive!" After that, get on the horse and lead the army out. Liu Bei is responsible for Ma Chao's drinking in the city. Before the banquet, Zilong had beheaded them and presented them to the banquet. Ma Chao is also surprised and respectful.

After Ma Chao surrendered, Liu Bei said, I will treat you well. Unexpectedly, Liu Zhang sent two generals and Zhao Yun went to war. As a result, before the banquet started, Zhao Yun came back to slay the two generals and convinced Ma Chao. Is this Zhao Yun too fierce?

It should be noted that Ma Chao did not admire Zhang Fei when he hit him. Instead, he satirized Zhang Fei: "My family has been waiting for generations and I don't know the people in the countryside." But now seeing Zhao Yun so brave, Ma Chao is "surprised" and respects Zhao Yun. The so-called expert, as soon as you reach out, you will know whether there is one. From the analysis of Ma Chao's psychological activities, it is obvious that he is a little afraid of Zhao Yun.

Of course, this is only based on the analysis of the contents in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. As the saying goes, different people have different opinions. Blame Luo Guanzhong, why do you have to let Zhang Fei beat Ma Chao?

It should be noted that Ma Chao has already fought against the same type of valiant soldier Chu Xu, and now there is another Zhang Fei. Isn't this a repetition? Could it be that in the official history, Ma Chaozhen and Zhang Fei had a fight? I searched all the historical materials of the Three Kingdoms, but I couldn't find them.

So I can only say that I'm afraid Luo Guanzhong is afraid to let Zhao Yun play against Ma Chao. He thought it was impossible to draw, so he simply arranged a play. Since there is no way to distinguish between high and low in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, who is better than Ma Chao or Zhao Yun based on the official history of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms? I have to say: they are not in the same class at all.

Second, two characteristics of Zhao Yun in the official history

In the official history, Zhao Yun defected to Gongsun Zan for the first time. At that time, Gongsun Zan was surprised and asked Zhao Yun: Are you from Jizhou? Why don't you hang out with Yuan Shao and come to me instead? Zhao Yun's answer is very powerful: Now the world is in chaos and life is ruined. Only kind people will follow me.

This sentence made Gongsun Zan very satisfied, but it also made Liu Bei's eyes shine when he came to take refuge in Gongsun Zan. From then on, I began to take the initiative to talk to Zhao Yun, which laid the foundation for their cooperation. When Zhao Yun left Gongsun Zan, Liu Bei knew that Zhao Yun had seen through Gongsun Zan and would never come back, so he took Zhao Yun's hand and was reluctant to let go until Zhao Yun said, "I will never betray you".

From then on, Zhao Yun recognized Liu Bei as the boss. When Liu Bei took refuge in Yuan Shao, Zhao Yun also recruited a team for Liu Bei, which was equivalent to taking capital as a shareholder. So why do you want to introduce these things of Zhao Yun? Because only by understanding the initial state of Zhao Yun and Liu Bei can we understand why Zhao Yun is special in Liu Bei Group for two reasons!

First, Zhao Yun's moral character is very high. This is actually why Liu Bei always seems to be a little estranged from Zhao Yun. For example, after the capture of Hanzhong, Liu Bei used neither Zhang Fei nor Zhao Yun, but Wei Yan as the satrap of Hanzhong. It is not that Zhao Yun is inferior to Wei Yan, but that the higher his moral character, the less he develops and the more bound by rules and regulations. Therefore, being independent and cutting through thorns is Zhao Yun's weakness.

From this, we can understand why Liu Bei used Zhao Yun as a "big housekeeper" to restrain his overbearing wife. And why Liu Bei dared to entrust his life to Zhao Yun.

So much so that Zhao Yun is nothing more than Liu Bei's bodyguard. But is this kind of bodyguard too extravagant for Liu Bei? How stupid Liu Bei should be to position Zhao Yun as a bodyguard-evidence is Zhao Yun's second characteristic!

Second: Zhao Yun must be skilled in martial arts. From the death of Liu Bei, if you want to get Zhao Yun, you know that Zhao Yun's martial arts must be very high. If martial arts is not good, Liu Bei will be so concerned. Because conquering the world requires hard power (martial arts). Facts have also proved this speculation. Zhao Yun has always appeared as a military commander (main rider) since he followed Liu Bei. If he is not good at martial arts, how can he have fun with Guan Yu and Zhang Fei?

Another example is the battle of Changbanpo. Although The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is exaggerated, Zhao Yun was able to protect Mrs. Gan and get away with it. I'm not sure how many thrilling battles I've experienced. The reason why Zhao Yun was not besieged can only prove that Zhao Yun used the sharpest tactics at that time to eliminate the threat and solve the battle in the shortest time.

Therefore, Zhao Yun's martial arts should be a biting style of "if you don't act rashly, you will die". Otherwise can't explain, he can protect Mrs Gump and sinus escape-by hiding? Hide? Just kidding! That's Cao Cao's most elite butch riding. Cao Cao was so cruel that he had to kill Liu Bei. This is also why the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is the logic of the battle of Zhao Yunchang Banpo.

Three, Ma Chao's two characteristics in the official history

Ma Chao is one of the few princes in the Three Kingdoms who greatly hurt and insulted Cao Cao! Only in the early days of Cao Cao, Lu Bu almost killed Cao Cao when he was slaughtering Xuzhou. Ma Chao, at his strongest, almost blew Cao Cao away. Therefore, there is a folk saying that "Golden Lyu3 bu4, Silver Ma Chao".

However, I think it should be the other way around. It is more suitable for Chao and Yin Lu Bu-Ma Chao is more difficult to blow up Cao Cao than Lu Bu. Judging from the operational characteristics of Ma Chao, he is a typical "field king", that is to say, it is Ma Chao's bravery to lead the cavalry to make a crazy assault on the open battlefield.

But Ma Chao's fighting style must have an equally powerful deputy, who can deserve it, or he is brainless. This deputy is Bond!

Pound played a great role in the success of Ma Chao. This is actually why Ma Chao did not do much when he left Pound to surrender to Liu Bei.

You let Zhang Fei cooperate with Ma Chao? Do you believe that Zhang Fei will cooperate with him? Don't even think about it! For example, Ma Chao and Zhang Fei were defeated by Cao Hong at the beginning of the Battle of Hanzhong. Why? Is who cooperate with who, who is the master who vice!

Therefore, Ma Chao's first characteristic is that he belongs to the "field king" and is a fierce general, but he must have the same excellent deputy to cooperate.

As for the second characteristic, personality is too problematic! As the author said before, his father Ma Teng is still in Cao Cao's hands, and he will turn against Cao Cao. Han Sui, who killed his mother, said: I don't want my father, I want you to be Han Sui.

It is said that Lu Bu is a baiwenhang. In fact, Ma Chao is more baiwenhang than Lu Bu. The so-called fight to the end, win the hearts of the people. Lu Bu was defeated by the people's hearts and was finally captured alive by his men and dedicated to Cao Cao!

Ma Chao is the same, nothing will be shown, but if he fails, he will never get up again. Even if he took refuge in Zhang Lu, he was subjected to various runs and precautions. When I arrived at Liu Bei, I became a "vase"-the text was Xu Jing, the martial arts was Ma Chao, and the official position was the largest, but the real power was almost absent.

Fourth, general analysis.

By analyzing the characteristics of Zhao Yun and Ma Chao in the official history, it is obvious that we can now draw a relatively objective conclusion, in a word: they are not in the same class at all.

Ma Chao is a big official but has no real power, while Zhao has almost no real power. Ma Chao is the field king of armies, and Zhao Yun is the all-powerful killer. Ma Chao's personality is too problematic, but Zhao Yun is virtuous.

So the conclusion is: Zhao Yun is obviously higher than Ma Chao in grade. Because of these two characteristics, Ma Chao is doomed to be like a meteor fireworks, which instantly blooms with dazzling light. After blasting Cao Cao once, he lost his luster and fell silent, while Zhao Yun was so radiant that he was praised as a perfect general.

Who is stronger, Ma Chao or Zhao Yun? 2 Ma Chao is stronger than Zhao Yunqiang?

The debate about who is better, Ma Chao or Zhao Yun, has always been a hot topic, and no one can convince anyone. If you don't look at the duel between Ma Chao and Zhao Yun, judging from their respective records, in fact, both of them are almost the same, and it is difficult to distinguish them.

For example, in the Battle of Rangshan, Zhao Yun and Chu Xu were tied for 30 rounds, and then confronted each other many times, but they never won. In the battle of Weishui, Ma Chao and Chu Xu played 200 rounds, but they failed to win, and their fighting power was not much different!

From the perspective of Ma Chao's supporters, Tongguan's war horse beat Zhang He in over 20 rounds, which shows Ma Chao's courage. In the Battle of Rangshan, Zhao Yun defeated Zhang He and spent thirty rounds. Thus, Ma Chao's fighting capacity is more than Zhao Yun's.

However, from the perspective of Zhao Yun's supporters, Zhao Yun played from morning till night in the Battle of Rangshan. He first fought Chu Xu, Yu Jin and Li Dian, and then searched for Liu Bei non-stop. He didn't have much rest, and his physical strength was no longer at its peak. He defeated Zhang He in thirty rounds.

If Zhao Yun is at the peak of his physical strength, he will definitely win Z Ryan in 20 rounds! Later, Zhang He and Huang Xu joined forces and met Zhao Yun, which just proved the power gap between Zhang He and Zhao Yun!

In fact, in this article, it is difficult to tell who is stronger from the evaluation of outsiders and the record of Ma Chao and Zhao Yun! Because choose different objects, the conclusion will be completely different! For this level of Athens, there must be a personal contest between them if you want to win or lose!

Many people will say that Ma Chao and Zhao Yun are both Liu Bei's people and teammates, so it is impossible to fight! In fact, when Liu Bei attacked Yizhou, Ma Chao and Zhao Yun had a confrontation! It's just that this clip is not long, so many people ignore it!

The first meeting between Ma Chao and Zhao Yun.

At the invitation of Liu Zhang, Liu Bei went to give up to help resist Zhang Lu. Therefore, Liu Beixin has different ambitions. He didn't want to attack Zhang Lu, but Liu Zhang!

Liu Bei was quite embarrassed at first. After all, Liu Zhang didn't do anything wrong to him. He has no good reason to attack Liu Zhang. But with the death of Zhang Song, Liu Bei realized that he and Liu Zhang had to break up, so he ordered his men to attack Liu Zhang! Liu Bei led a team to attack Liu Zhang and handed Meng Jiaguan in the rear to Huo Jun to help him resist Zhang Lu.

Zhang Lu, unwilling to be lonely, wanted to fish in troubled waters. When Liu Bei attacked Liu Zhang, he sent troops to capture Meng Jiaguan. The man sent by Zhang Lu to attack Guan is Ma Chao, and Ma Chao is a world-famous warrior, so Huo Jun had to ask Liu Bei for help.

Liu Bei is a man who has seen the world. Knowing Ma Chao's strength, he dare not consult Zhuge Liang immediately. Zhuge Liang's suggestion is that Ma Chao is brave, and he should send a valiant soldier like Zhang Fei or Zhao Yun to attack. At that time, Zhao Yun was performing military affairs outside and couldn't get away. At this time, he could only send Zhang Fei to fight against Ma Chao. So the wonderful battle broke out. The final result was that Ma Chao and Zhang Fei were tied, and no one could beat each other, so the two sides made an appointment to fight again the next day.

Zhang Fei has a bad temper and is never afraid of anyone. Because of an appointment with Ma Chao, he is going to fight again the next day. I don't know that Zhuge Liang suddenly appeared. He thinks that Zhang Fei and Ma Chao are both brave fighters. Once they fight to the death, they will definitely hurt one side, so he decided to use tactics to surrender Ma Chao! Liu Bei thought it was a good idea, so he ordered Zhuge Liang to implement it at once. In this way, Ma Chao and Zhang Fei never fought again, because he was persuaded by Zhuge Liang!

Ma Chao, who was supported by others in Zhang Lu at that time, was excluded, so he was unhappy, which coincided with Zhuge Liang's surrender. He felt that following Liu Bei was more promising and more likely to defeat Cao Cao, so he abandoned Zhang Lu and surrendered to Liu Bei!

The second statement is clear and consistent with the conspiracy theory circulating on the Internet. Therefore, everyone firmly believes that Zhao Yun's move is deliberately suppressing and intimidating Ma Chao. The purpose is to remind Ma Chao to pay attention to his identity and not to think about being equal to Liu Bei. However, in this article, this second view is a bit too interpreted!

Ma Chao was really unruly at first, but with the defeat of Liangzhou, Ma Chao has lost his former position and entered a state of being dependent on others. In Zhang Lu, Hanzhong, Ma Chao actually had a bad life, and everyone around Zhang Lu was afraid of Ma Chao.

And Zhang Lu, who is not a monarch, is increasingly alienated from Ma Chao, so Ma Chao actually has no future in the Zhang Lu camp, but he should always be on guard against the sinister villain. It is for this reason that Ma Chao finally took refuge in Liu Bei! To put it bluntly, Ma Chao is desperate, and it is his best choice to take refuge in Liu Bei! This can be seen from Ma Chao's first sentence when he met Liu Bei!

At that time, Ma Chao said, "If you meet a wise master today, you will see the sky like a cloud." This shows that Ma Chao really surrendered to Liu Bei and did not show any behavior beyond the rules. Moreover, Ma Chao is not stupid, he is desperate. Someone took him in. He should behave well! Show a defiant look, isn't this a death wish?

Ma Chao expressed absolute obedience to Liu Bei, and Liu Bei could no longer deliberately suppress Ma Chao. Besides, it was clearly stated in the original text that Liu Bei and others had just arrived in Mianzhu when people from Liu Zhang called. In such a short time, Liu Bei can't let Zhao Yun suppress Ma Chao, can he?

Therefore, Liu Bei had no motive, no time arrangement, nor did he let Zhao Yun deliberately suppress Ma Chao. Ma Chao was surprised, not because of the warning, but really shocked by Zhao Yun's military performance!

In addition, Ma Chao was surprised by the word "Ye", which means "Ye". Ma Chao was also surprised, that is to say, all the people present at that time were actually shocked by Zhao Yun's force. Everyone didn't expect Zhao Yun to cut off the enemy's head in such a short time!

Ma Chao's second reaction is to be more respectful! At the battle of Changbanpo, Zhao Yun's reputation resounded all over the world. Ma Chao must know Zhao Yun's name, and his martial arts is also very high. I just didn't expect Zhao Yunqiang to reach this level.

It can also be beheaded in such a short time. If this is changed to himself, it is estimated that it is finished! That's why he will be more respectful! I want to ask, if Zhao Yun can finish this record, is it necessary to make him more shocked and respected?

Ma Chao's third reaction is to take the initiative to fight! Ma Chao called Liu Bei the master in public and took the initiative to attack Liu Zhang, which actually confirmed the first point. Ma Chao really surrendered to Liu Bei. He was not rebellious. And d see zhaoyun so strong, not to be outdone. He wants to go home, and he won't be beaten by Zhao Yun. As fast as Zhao Yun, it is estimated that Ma Chao can't finish it, so he knelt down and attacked Liu Zhang!

Who is stronger, Ma Chao or Zhao Yun? 3. Comparison of battlefield performance between Ma Chao and Zhao Yun;

Ma Chao's record;

In the battle of Tongguan, Ma Chao was defeated by the ban in the seventh and eighth rounds, and Zhang He was defeated in the twentieth round. He shot Cao Jiang Li Tong to death, then killed Cao Cao, cut his beard and abandoned his robe, and fled in a hurry. Later, he fought Chu Xu, the first valiant soldier of Cao Cao, for more than 200 rounds, regardless of the outcome;

In the battle of Guan, Ma Chao fought Zhang Fei, a ten thousand enemy under Liu Bei. They played more than 200 rounds from morning till night and finally got a draw.

Part of Zhao Yun's record;

Zhao Yun, who just debuted, and Yuan Shao, who ranked second, tied for sixty rounds;

Gao Lan fought with Zhao Yun, who stabbed him to death.

Zhao Yun played against Zhang He. After thirty rounds, Zhang He fled in defeat.

In the Battle of Mount Hong, Zhao Yun was besieged by Chu Xu, Yu Jin and Li Dian, the best soldiers of Cao Cao, to save Liu Bei. Of course, the battle ended in zhaoyun unscathed.

In the battle of Changbanpo, Zhao Yun entered the Cao Cao camp alone. After Zhao Yun found his little master Dou, he was like nobody's business in Cao Cao's million-strong army. Not only that, Zhao Yun also killed more than 50 soldiers under Cao Cao in this battle.

In the Battle of Mount Mountain, Zhao Yun, who was nearly seventy years old, first killed Hande and his son five times in a row. Later, Zhao Yun was besieged by Xia Houmao's eight generals, but in the end he broke through the encirclement.

Judging from the record of Ma Chao and Zhao Yun, Ma Chao was not as active as Zhao Yun during the Three Kingdoms period, and his record was not as good as Zhao Yun's. So judging from their battlefield performance, Zhao Yun is superior to Ma.

The quantity and quality of beheadings by Ma Chao and Zhao Yun;

Among the Three Kingdoms, Ma Chao killed four famous people named * * *, namely Wang Fang, Li Tong, Ma Wan and Liang Xing; Moreover, the number of generals killed by Zhao Yun is very considerable. There are 23 famous generals with surnames, namely: Ju Shou, Pei, Gao Lan, Zhang Wu, Lv Kuang, Chun Yudao, Xia Houen, Yan Ming, Zhong You, Zhong Shen, Xing Daorong, Liu Qin, Mahan, Murong Lie, Jiao Bing and Zhu Ran.

Judging from the number of generals beheaded by Ma Chao and Zhao Yun, Ma Chao only killed four generals, and none of them were famous. And Zhao Yun killed 23 generals, including Juyi, Gao Lan and Zhu Ran, who were famous soldiers at that time. Of course, among these 23 people, Punishment Rong was later named "God will". Therefore, judging from the quantity and quality of these two beheadings, Zhao Yun was more powerful than Ma Chao.

Through the comparison of the above two aspects, it can be seen that Zhao Yun is superior to Ma Chao in both battlefield performance and the quantity and quality of beheadings. So compared with Ma Chao and Zhao Yun, Zhao Yun is more powerful!