List of 50 typical cases of intellectual property judicial protection in Chinese courts in 2009

1. Intellectual property civil cases (46 cases)

(1) Patent infringement cases (5 cases)

1. OBE-Factory·Onmacht & Baumgartner Co., Ltd. v. Zhejiang Kanghua Optical Co., Ltd. Retrial Application for Invention Patent Infringement Dispute [Supreme People's Court (2008) ) Civil Ruling No. 980]

2. Beijing Intelligent Morgan Thermal Ceramics Textile Co., Ltd. v. Beijing Deyuan Express Doors and Windows Factory Appeal Case on Invention Patent Infringement Dispute [Beijing Higher People’s Court (2009) Gao Minzhongzi Civil Judgment No. 4721]

3. (Japan) Izumi Co., Ltd. v. Guangzhou Meishi Jingying Screen Co., Ltd. and Beijing Renhe Century Technology Co., Ltd. appeal for infringement of utility model patent rights Case [Beijing Higher People’s Court (2008) Gao Minzhong Zi Civil Judgment No. 941]

4. Appeal case of patent infringement dispute between 3M Company of the United States v. Shandong Shuangqiu Protective Equipment Co., Ltd. [Shandong Province Senior People's Court (2008) Lu Minsan Zhongzi Civil Judgment No. 158]

5. Wang Shichang, Hebei Weida Architectural Design Co., Ltd. v. Shuangyashan City Chenguang Real Estate Development Co., Ltd. Appeal case of dispute over infringement of invention patent rights [ Heilongjiang Provincial Higher People's Court (2009) Heizhizhongzi No. 41 Civil Judgment]

(2) New plant variety infringement case (1 case)

6. Yangling New Northwest Plant Industry Co., Ltd. v. Shaanxi Province Jingyang County Modern Seed Industry Co., Ltd. Appeal case of dispute over infringement of new plant variety rights [Shaanxi Provincial Higher People’s Court (2009) Shaanmin Sanzhongzi No. 42 Civil Judgment]

( 3) Copyright infringement cases (11 cases)

7. Xuzhou Huaihai Drama King Audio and Video Co., Ltd. v. Xinyi TV Station, third party Ding Xiangyu, Liu Hanfei, and Zhang Yinxia appeal case over copyright infringement disputes [Jiangsu Provincial Higher People’s Court (2009) Su Min San Zhong Zi Civil Judgment No. 0250]

8. Shanghai Dichuang Network Technology Co., Ltd. and Shanghai Wange Scientific Equipment Co., Ltd. v. Beijing Wanhu Ming Media Technology Co., Ltd. and Beijing Wange Case of dispute over computer software copyright infringement by Huname Media Technology Co., Ltd. Shanghai Branch [Shanghai Pudong New District People’s Court (2008) Pu Min San (Zhi) Chu Zi No. 453 Civil Judgment]

9. China Friendship Publishing Company v. Zhejiang Taobao Network Co., Ltd., Yang Hailin Appeal Case of Copyright Infringement Dispute [Beijing No. 2 Intermediate People’s Court (2009) Er Zhong Min Zhong Zi No. 15423 Civil Judgment]

10. (U.S.) Microsoft Company v. Beijing Sichuang Future Technology Development Co., Ltd. Appeal case over computer software copyright infringement [Beijing Higher People’s Court (2009) Gao Minzhong Zi Civil Judgment No. 4462]

11. Beijing Ciwen Film and Television Production Co., Ltd. v. China Network Communications Group Corporation Hainan Branch Retrial Case for Copyright Infringement Dispute [Supreme People's Court (2009) Civil Judgment No. 17]

12. Zhu Deyong v. Liaoning Northeast Network Station Infringement Copyright dispute case [Shenyang Intermediate People's Court of Liaoning Province (2009) Shen Zhongmin Sichuzi No. 97 Civil Judgment]

13. Beijing Wangshang Culture Communication Co., Ltd. v. Yinchuan Sunshine Unlimited Network Co., Ltd. for infringement of copyright property rights Dispute case [Yinchuan Intermediate People's Court of Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region (2009) Yinminzhichuzi No. 41 Civil Judgment]

14. Wu Siou and others sued Shanghai Painting and Calligraphy Publishing House and Xinhua Bookstore in Suzhou City, Jiangsu Province for infringement of works Property rights dispute appeal case [Jiangsu Provincial Higher People’s Court (2009) Su Minsan Zhongzi No. 0101 Civil Judgment]

15. Song Enterprise Company v. Zhuhai Publishing House and Shanghai Xinhua Media Chain Co., Ltd. for copyright infringement Property rights dispute case [Shanghai Huangpu District People’s Court (2007) Huang Minsan (Zhi) Chuzi No. 75 Civil Judgment]

>

16. Bi Shumin v. Huaibei Experimental Senior High School Copyright Infringement Dispute Appeal Case [Anhui Provincial Higher People’s Court (2009) Wanmin Sanzhongzi No. 0014 Civil Judgment]

17. Huang Tianyuan v. Appeal case of copyright infringement dispute between Inner Mongolia University Press and Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region Foreign Language Bookstore [Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region Higher People’s Court (2009) Guimin Sanzhongzi No. 48 Civil Judgment]

(4) Trademark Infringement Cases ( 16 cases)

18. Shandong Taihe Century Investment Co., Ltd. and Jinan Honghe Beverage Preparation Business Department v. Yunnan Chengtou Real Estate Co., Ltd. Retrial case of dispute over trademark infringement [Supreme People's Court (2008) Mintizi Civil Judgment No. 52]

19. Pfizer Co., Ltd., Pfizer Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd. v. Bankruptcy Liquidation Team of Shanghai Oriental Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd., Beijing Health New Concept Pharmacy Co., Ltd., Guangzhou Wellman Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd. Case of retrial application for disputes over unfair competition and infringement of unregistered well-known trademark rights [Supreme People's Court (2009) Civil Ruling No. 313]

20. Goubuli Group Co., Ltd. v. Jinan City Grand View Garden Retrial application for trademark infringement by Tianfengyuan Hotel in a shopping mall [Supreme People’s Court (2008) Civil Ruling No. 10-1]

21. Zhangzhou Pien Tze Huang Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd. v. Zhangzhou Hongning Jiaqi Co., Ltd.’s application for retrial of the trademark infringement dispute [Supreme People’s Court (2009) Civil Ruling No. 1310]

22. Sichuan Tengwangge Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd. v. Sichuan Bao Appeal case of Ning Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd.’s trademark infringement dispute [Sichuan Provincial Higher People’s Court (2009) Civil Judgment No. 155]

23. Fujian Baisha Fire Industry and Trade Co., Ltd. v. Nan’an City Appeal case of Baisha Fire Fighting Equipment Co., Ltd.’s infringement of corporate name (trade name) rights and unfair competition disputes [Fujian Provincial Higher People’s Court (2008) Minmin Zhongzi No. 514 Civil Judgment]

24. Chevron Global Energy Company v. Jinan Caltex Lubricant Co., Ltd. and Jinan Tengfeida Petrochemical Co., Ltd. Appeal case over unfair competition and trademark infringement disputes [Shandong Provincial Higher People’s Court (2009) Lu Minsan Zhongzi No. 194 Civil Judgment ]

25. Louis Vuitton Maliti (France) v. Time Gallery (Guangdong) Watch Co., Ltd., Xiongteng (Shanghai) Trading Co., Ltd., Shenzhen Jinguanghua Commercial Co., Ltd. Dispute over trademark infringement Appeal case [Guangdong Provincial Higher People’s Court (2008) Yue Gao Fa Min San Zhong Zi Civil Judgment No. 345]

26. Jiangxi Ant Logistics Co., Ltd., Chengdu Ant Logistics Co., Ltd. v. Nanchang Ant Moving Service Co., Ltd. Appeal case of trademark infringement and unfair competition dispute [Jiangxi Provincial Higher People’s Court (2009) Ganmin Sanzhongzi No. 20 Civil Judgment]

27. Michelin Group Corporation v. Tianjin Michelin Electric Bicycle Co., Ltd. Case of dispute over company infringement of trademark exclusive rights [Tianjin No. 2 Intermediate People’s Court (2008) Er Zhong Min San Chu Zi No. 3 Civil Judgment]

28. Wang Meiyan v. Zhejiang Hangzhou Xinhua Bookstore Co., Ltd., Guangdong Appeal case of Zhongkai Cultural Development Co., Ltd.’s trademark infringement dispute [Zhejiang Provincial Higher People’s Court (2009) Zhezhizhongzi No. 98 Civil Judgment]

29. Guzhang Tea Industry Development Research Center v. Hunan Provincial Huaming Tea Co., Ltd. and Hunan Pinghetang Industrial Co., Ltd.’s trademark infringement dispute case [Hunan Province Changsha City Tianxin District People’s Court (2008) Tianminchuzi No. 2500 Civil Judgment]

30. Louis Vuitton Malitti (France) v. Lin Yizhong, Shanghai Zhongwen Trading Co., Ltd., and Wu Beiwen Case of Trademark Infringement Dispute [Shanghai No. 1 Intermediate People’s Court (2009) Shanghai No. 1 Zhong Min Wu (Zhi) Chu Zi No. 34 Civil Judgment]

31. Cartier International Co., Ltd. v. Yunnan Cartier Wedding Photography Co., Ltd. Appeal case of trademark infringement and unfair competition dispute [Yunnan Provincial Higher People’s Court (2009) Yungao Min Sanzhong Zi No. Civil Judgment No. 35]

32. Appeal case of Chen Guoming v. Hainan Provincial People’s Hospital over trademark infringement dispute [Hainan Provincial Higher People’s Court (2009) Qiongmin Sanzhongzi No. 25 Civil Judgment]

33 , China Kweichow Moutai Distillery Co., Ltd. v. Chongqing Southern Junlin Hotel Co., Ltd. Appeal case of trademark infringement dispute [Chongqing Higher People’s Court (2009) Yugao Faminzhongzi No. 159 Civil Judgment]

（ 5) Unfair competition cases (10 cases)

34. Shandong Crane Factory Co., Ltd. v. Shandong Shanqi Heavy Industry Co., Ltd. Application for retrial of the dispute over infringement of corporate name rights [Supreme People's Court (2008) Minshen Zi No. Civil Ruling No. 758]

35. Shanghai Dongyong Shengtang Food Co., Ltd. v. Shanghai Dongyong Pier Catering Management Co., Ltd. Unfair Competition Dispute Complaint [Supreme People's Court (2007) Civil Sanjian Zi No. 21-1 Civil Ruling No.]

36. Castrol Limited (UK) v. Yao Yuxin, Castrol International Petroleum Group (Hong Kong) Co., Ltd., Ningbo Yinzhou Jiashuai Lubricant Factory Unfair Competition Dispute Case [ Shanghai No. 2 Intermediate People’s Court (2008) Shanghai No. 2 Intermediate People’s Court Civil Judgment No. 91]

37. Sichuan Jiangkou Chun Liquor Industry (Group) Co., Ltd. v. Luzhou Jiaguan Liquor Co., Ltd., Lin Jinquan’s appeal case over unfair competition and trademark infringement disputes [Guangdong Provincial Higher People’s Court (2007) Guangdong High Court Fa Min San Zhong Zi No. 318 Civil Judgment]

38, Anhui Huaxin Biotech Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd. v. Jiangxi Caohuan Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd. and Anhui Baixingyuan Pharmacy Chain Co., Ltd. An appeal case involving a dispute over the unauthorized use of the unique name, packaging, and decoration of well-known products [Anhui Provincial Higher People’s Court (2009) Wan Min San Zhong Zi No. Civil Judgment No. 0026]

39. Dalian Ruite Building Materials Co., Ltd. and Dalian Zhongde Perlite Factory v. Liu Jiawang Unfair Competition Dispute [Dalian Intermediate People’s Court of Liaoning Province (2009) Damin Sichuzi Civil Judgment No. 237]

40. Unfair Competition Dispute Case of Century Jinyuan Investment Group Co., Ltd. v. Henan Century Jinyuan Real Estate Co., Ltd. [Henan Provincial Higher People’s Court (2009) Yu Fa Min San Zhong Zi Civil Mediation No. 12 and Zhengzhou Intermediate People’s Court (2007) Zheng Minsanchuzi Civil Judgment No. 274]

41. Xinjiang Wusu Beer Co., Ltd. v. Yili Yugong Beer Co., Ltd. and others for unauthorized use Appeal case on disputes over the unique name, packaging and decoration of well-known commodities [Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region Higher People’s Court (2009) Xinmin Sanzhongzi No. 21 Civil Judgment]

42. Chongqing Silver Wings Culture Media Co., Ltd. v. Chongqing Communications University, Chongqing Fantawild Tourism Co., Ltd. False Publicity Dispute Case [Chongqing Fifth Intermediate People’s Court (2009) Yuwu Zhongfa Minchuzi No. 247 Civil Judgment]

43, Xiamen Zhengxin Rubber Industrial Co., Ltd. v. Tianjin Haowen Technology Co., Ltd. and Zhengxin Tire (Taiwan) Holding Group Co., Ltd. Dispute over unauthorized use of other people’s business names [Tianjin Second Intermediate People’s Court (2008) Er Zhong Min San Chu Zi No. 78 Civil Mediation Book]

(6) Intellectual property contract cases (3 cases)

44. Shandong Jufeng Network Co., Ltd. v. South Korea MGAME Company, the third party Tianjin Fengyun Network Technology Co., Ltd. Network Appeal case of objection to jurisdiction over game agency and licensing contract disputes [Supreme People’s Court (2009) Civil Ruling No. 4]

45. Shenzhen Shuoxing Transportation Electronic Equipment Co., Ltd. v. Yuhuanlong China Locomotive Parts Co., Ltd.’s application for retrial of patent licensing and technical service contract disputes [Supreme People’s Court (2009) Civil Ruling No. 1325]

46. Liu Faxin v. Jiyuan City Agricultural Science Research Appeal case on reward disputes for persons who accomplished technical achievements in the institute [Henan Provincial Higher People’s Court (2009) Yu Fa Min San Zhong Zi No. 75 Civil Judgment]

II. Intellectual Property Administrative Cases (3 cases)

(1) Patent authorization and confirmation cases (2 cases)

4

7. Linhai Jinlilong Shoes Co., Ltd. sued the Patent Reexamination Committee of the State Intellectual Property Office, the third party Zhejiang Sanmen County Adhesive Tape Products Factory, and Linhai Baotian Track Manufacturing Co., Ltd. Patent Invalidation Administrative Dispute Application for Retrial Case [Supreme People's Court (2006 ) Notice of Rejection of Reexamination Application No. 32-2 of the Supervisory Office]

48. Avantis Pharmaceuticals Co., Ltd. v. Patent Reexamination Committee of the State Intellectual Property Office of the People’s Republic of China and the Third Party Jiangsu Hengrui Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd.’s Appeal Case on Administrative Disputes over the Invalidation of Invention Patents [Beijing Higher People’s Court (2009) Gao Xingzhongzi Administrative Judgment No. 1148]

(2) Trademark authorization and confirmation cases (1 Case)

49. Bayer Consumer Care Co., Ltd. v. Trademark Review and Adjudication Board of the State Administration for Industry and Commerce and the third party Southwest Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd. Trademark Administrative Dispute Retrial Case [Supreme People's Court (2009) Administrative Judgment No. 1]

3. Intellectual property criminal case (1 case)

50. Shanghai Changzheng Materials Co., Ltd., Tan Tian’s crime of selling counterfeit registered trademarks [ Shanghai Pudong New Area People's Court (2009) Pu Xingchu Zi No. 1824 Criminal Judgment]