How many users are hesitating about a question, "Which is better, QQ computer housekeeper or 360?" Next, let's discuss around this issue, which is better, QQ computer housekeeper or 360, and which groups are suitable for them respectively.
Windows 7 flagship SP 1 was used as the test operating system, and the security patch was as of March 20 12. Installation software includes: Adobe PhotoshopCS5, WinRAR, Microsoft Office 20 10, Microsoft Silverlight 4.1.10/.0, SnagIt 9.02, EmEditor8.04, Ie flash ActiveX11.1.102.63, Microsoft Pinyin 20655.
Before testing, make a Ghost backup of the system. After testing a test software, perform Ghost operation to restore the system to its initial state, and then test another software.
A, QQ computer housekeeper or 360, which system has a good security score?
At present, domestic security auxiliary software is popular to score the security of operating system. Of course, the higher the scoring system, the better. Basically, it is based on these aspects (whether the operating system has found high-risk vulnerabilities, whether there are risky files, whether there are malicious plug-ins, whether it has been scanned by virus Trojans recently, and whether anti-virus software has been installed). Then, let's take a look at the scores of 360 security guards and QQ computer housekeeper evaluating the security of our computer operating system.
360 security guards scored the system (38 points) and evaluated the score (in a very dangerous state), which took 83 seconds.
◆ 8 high-risk vulnerabilities (including system and Microsoft Office).
◆ Abnormal items in browser favorites (4 items).
◆ No antivirus software is installed (click "Install" to repair, and 360 antivirus will be installed automatically).
◆ No system scan was performed.
◆ Found junk files.
◆ Boot startup program is prohibited.
◆ Found the bad review plug-in (template.vbs in the emeditor directory) false positive.
◆ It is recommended to use 360 security browser.
Figure 1 QQ computer housekeeper or 360 which is better: 360 security guards physical examination results.
Comments: The physical examination function of 360 security guards divides the test results into three categories: dangerous items, optimization items and safety items. The classification is clear and the test items are comprehensive.
QQ Computer Manager scores the system (59 points) and evaluates the score (if two risks are found, please optimize immediately), and the scoring takes 26 seconds.
◆ IE risk item.
◆ 7 high-risk vulnerabilities (including system and Microsoft Office).
◆ The home page is not locked.
◆ No antivirus software is installed.
◆ 4 models of upgradeable software.
◆ Found junk files.
◆ I haven't scanned Trojans recently.
◆ There are too many startup projects.
Figure 2 Which is better, QQ computer housekeeper or 360: QQ computer housekeeper system score.
Comments: The physical examination function of QQ computer housekeeper divides the test results into three categories: system risk item, optimizable item and safety item. The classification is clear, and there are no projects that mislead users to install other software.
Summary of this comparison: 360 security guards and QQ computer housekeeper have detected high-risk vulnerabilities, whether there are risk files, whether there are malicious plug-ins, whether they have scanned virus Trojans recently, whether they have installed anti-virus software, and have given solutions.
The difference is that anti-virus software is not installed. 360 security guards only provide 360 antivirus, while QQ housekeeper recommends a variety of mainstream antivirus software for users to choose from. In addition, 360 security guards suggest using 360 security browsers, which is also suspected of being forced in disguise. QQ computer housekeeper's score is high, which is more reasonable and faster in my opinion.
2 housekeeper PK guardian vulnerability detection and repair returned to the peak
Second, which system vulnerability detection and repair is QQ computer housekeeper and 360?
At present, there are many loopholes in the system and software. As users, what we can do is to fix the vulnerabilities in time after the relevant manufacturers release the vulnerability patches to prevent these vulnerabilities from being exploited by hackers. Figuratively speaking, loopholes are like gaps in ancient city walls. If it is not repaired in time, it will lead to enemy invasion and the fall of the city. One of the most important functions of security assistant software is to help users automatically detect vulnerability patches released by manufacturers and automatically download and install these patches.
For windows users, there are several kinds of patches that are most important at present: windows itself, Flash Activex and various application software patches. Let's take a look at the patching ability of 360 security guards and QQ computer butlers.
Let's take a look at the vulnerability patches that need to be upgraded detected by using Windows Update, the upgrade tool that comes with the system.
◆ 12 detected an important update (kb2598039kb982726kb2553267kb2553406kb2679255kb290830 (malware removal tool) kb2656373kb2675157kb157).
◆ 35 optional updates have been detected (except one for Microsoft security, all others are national language packs).
Figure 3 Windows Update Detection
360 security guards have detected vulnerabilities that need to be upgraded, and it takes time to download and install them.
◆ Eight high-risk vulnerabilities (KB 2653956 KB 2675157 KB 2656373 KB 982726 KB 2553248 KB 2553267 KB 2553406 KB 2598039) were detected.
◆ 26 functional update patches were detected.
◆ You can save the source file of the service package.
◆ Patch download path can be customized.
◆ It can automatically repair high-risk vulnerabilities.
◆ It can be downloaded when patching or completely downloaded before installation.
◆ It takes 9 minutes and 26 seconds to download and install high-risk vulnerability patches, and the average patch download speed is about 200 KB/s. ..
◆ Restart the computer after installing the patch and detect a high-risk vulnerability again (Flash Player security update KB370049).
Figure 4 Which is the better test result of QQ computer housekeeper or 360: 360 security guard?
Comments: 360 security guards detect vulnerabilities quickly, but download patches slowly. However, a user-defined patch download path is provided, which is convenient for local area network users to download patches using the intranet server. I don't know why the Flash Player security update patch was not detected in the first detection, but it was successfully detected in the second detection.
The vulnerability patch detected by QQ computer manager needs to be upgraded, and it takes time to download and install.
◆ Seven high-risk vulnerabilities (KB 2500170 KB 982772620 KB 2653956 KB 2598039 KB 2675157 KB 2656373 Flash Player) were detected.
◆ 2 1 functional update patches have been detected.
◆ It is detected that it is not recommended to install the 1 patch (windows malware removal tool).
◆ You can save the source file of the service package.
◆ It can automatically repair high-risk vulnerabilities.
◆ It takes 2 minutes 12 seconds to download and install high-risk vulnerability patches, and the average patch download speed is about 300 KB/s. ..
Figure 5 Which is better, QQ computer housekeeper or 360: QQ computer housekeeper detection.
Comments: QQ computer housekeeper has a fast function of fixing vulnerabilities and downloading patches.
Summary of this comparison: It can be seen that the number of high-risk vulnerabilities detected by the two participating softwares is not only different, but also the patches are not the same. Compared with Windows Update, QQ Computer Manager lacks two Office patches KB982726 KB2553248 in vulnerability detection.
In addition, QQ Computer Manager does not have the function of selecting all patches, and users need to select them one by one (for functional patches). 360 security guards' vulnerability detection and repair are more accurate. By the way, not all patches must be installed, and some patches that are not necessarily downloaded and installed will consume extra download time and bandwidth, and will consume system resources and affect stability.
3 Real-time monitoring of cross-sectional QQ contrast 360 back to the top
3. Which real-time monitoring is better, QQ computer housekeeper or 360?
In addition to doing a good job in repairing the city wall, we should also prevent the enemy from using various means to mix into the city to destroy it. The big fish is caught by anti-virus software, and the security auxiliary software should pay attention to the details to prevent the fish from escaping the net.
360 security guards real-time monitoring project
◆ Entrance defense: web page security protection, chat security protection, download security protection, U disk security protection, and hacker intrusion protection.
◆ Isolation and protection: isolate watching films and operating risk files.
System defense: network security protection, keyboard record protection, file system protection, driver protection, process protection and registry protection.
Figure 6 QQ computer housekeeper or 360: 360 security guard real-time monitoring project
QQ Computer Housekeeper Real-time Monitoring Project
◆ System firewall (protecting system files, registry and processes).
◆ Web firewall.
◆ USB flash drive firewall.
◆ Camera protection.
◆ Property protection (chat/online shopping/online games).
◆ Download protection.
◆ Fragile firewall.
Figure 7 Which is better, QQ computer housekeeper or 360: QQ computer housekeeper real-time monitoring project.
Summary of this comparison: the protection function of 360 security guards is still relatively strong. Starting from the common intrusion methods of virus Trojans, plus the isolation protection function similar to Sandboxie and the simple HIPS function, this series of systems will protect the system more strictly.
The real-time protection function of QQ computer housekeeper is also more comprehensive, but compared with 360 security guards, there are still some functions missing. These two softwares have no real-time file monitoring function, that is, users are not monitored by them when they read/write/create/run files.
QQ computer housekeeper or 360 Trojan killing function is better.
Although security auxiliary software is still in the auxiliary position of antivirus software, with the continuous increase of function and performance, security auxiliary software tends to replace antivirus software. If you have installed security assistant software, why do you want to install anti-virus software? One reason is that security auxiliary software has no real-time file monitoring function, not that they can't realize it, but that they don't add it on purpose.
4. Comparison of antivirus engines used in1
Antivirus engine used by 360 antivirus software
◆ 360 cloud killing engine.
◆ 360 heuristic engine.
◆ QVM artificial intelligence engine (not turned on by default).
◆ Red Umbrella local engine (not turned on by default).
Anti-virus engine used by QQ computer housekeeper
◆ QQ computer housekeeper cloud killing engine.
◆ Jinshan cloud killing engine.
◆ Red Umbrella's murder this time.
◆ Trend local killing engine (not turned on by default).
Summary of this comparison: In terms of killing engines, QQ Computer Manager has assembled three well-known killing engines of antivirus software except himself, all of which are good at killing viruses, and three of the four engines used by 360 are their own.
4 virus package test QQ computer housekeeper and 360 back to the top
4.2 Comparison of Fast Scan Time
360 security guards fast scanning time
Need 1 min 3 1 sec.
◆ Found the residual script file of malicious programs (template.vbs in the emeditor directory).
Fig. 8 Which is better, QQ computer housekeeper or 360: 360 security guard?
QQ computer housekeeper fast scanning time
It takes 1 minute, 16 seconds.
◆ The desktop cleaning wizard function is abnormal (the author has closed it manually).
◆ There are 2 suspicious websites in IE favorites (there is nothing unusual about my visit).
Figure 9 Which is better, QQ computer housekeeper or 360: QQ computer housekeeper has a fast scanning time.
Summary of this comparison: both participating softwares have false positives, and the killing speed is within 2 minutes, and the quick scanning of QQ computer housekeeper takes less time.
4.3 virus package test comparison (open all engines)
Test items: The author collected some virus samples in major security forums, and all the collected viruses were popular in recent years and previous years (2000). Before the test, upgrade the participating software to the latest virus database and start all the attached killing engines. Other configurations default.
Personal collection is not extensive, this test is for reference only. The author uses the method of calculating the number of remaining files after scanning to determine the final score. So the way to deal with the virus is to delete or isolate it.
360 security guard virus package killing situation
◆ Found 188 1 security threats.
◆ After scanning, there are 127 files left in the virus package, and the virus killing rate is 93.65%.
Figure 10 QQ computer housekeeper or 360 which is better: 360 security guard virus package killing.
QQ computer housekeeper virus package killing situation
◆ Found 1909 security threat.
◆ After scanning, there are 120 files left in the virus package, and the virus killing rate is 94%.
Figure 1 1 QQ computer housekeeper or 360 which is better: QQ computer housekeeper virus package killing
Summary of this comparison: In this test, QQ computer housekeeper who gathered everyone's strength did well, with a virus killing rate of 94%, 360 security guards slightly lost, and a virus killing rate of 93.65%.
5. The hardware detection function is very strong, compared with the top.
5. Which is better, QQ computer housekeeper or 360 hardware detection function?
How is the performance of your computer? What brand and model are the accessories in the computer? When summer comes, the temperature of computer parts is too high, which will cause a crash. What is the temperature of CPU/ hard disk/motherboard? There is also a hardware driver, but it is more troublesome. How to install the driver?
At present, the hardware detection function is mostly added to the security auxiliary software to see if 360 security guards and QQ computer housekeepers can really identify the hardware. For the convenience of comparison, this test is carried out by the driver wizard 20 12 software specially designed for this item.
Driver Wizard Hardware Detection 20 12
◆ Three devices can be upgraded (AMD SMbus chip driver/sound card driver /usb driver).
◆ It is found that three drivers can be upgraded to the certified version (network card driver/fingerprint reader driver/infrared device driver).
Figure 12 QQ computer housekeeper or 360: which is better for the hardware check information of the driver wizard?
360 Hardware Master Hardware Detection and Tools
◆ Hardware identification.
◆ Driver management (no device needs to install drivers).
◆ Temperature monitoring (CPU graphics card temperature and CPU fan speed) (scroll display temperature with floating box).
◆ Performance test (comprehensive score of 2422).
◆ Power consumption estimation (approximate value is 228W).
◆ Energy-saving refrigeration function (off/intelligent refrigeration/overall energy saving).
◆ Attached display color quality test /LCD bad point test/hard disk bad track test tool.
Figure 13 QQ computer housekeeper or 360: 360 hardware master hardware detection and tools
Detection of QQ hardware detection function
◆ Hardware identification.
◆ Drive management (all installed).
◆ Temperature monitoring (CPU graphics card temperature and CPU fan speed) (dashboard with floating box, digital display CPU temperature and CPU memory occupancy).
◆ Performance test (the evaluation component needs to be updated. After testing the display performance of the first video card, users are required to upgrade the video card driver. After installing the latest graphics card driver, the fault still exists, so it cannot be tested).
Figure14 which is better, QQ computer housekeeper or 360: the detection of QQ hardware detection function
Summary of this comparison: The hardware identification function of the two participating softwares is good, and the hardware configuration of the author's computer has been successfully detected, but neither of them supports the driver upgrade function (supports the installation of the driver function). In temperature detection, QQ computer housekeeper does not support motherboard temperature detection, and the compatibility of performance testing function is not good. 360 security guards come with a variety of practical detection tools, which QQ computer housekeeper does not have.
8. Which is better, QQ computer housekeeper or 360 cleaning function optimization?
Optimized cleaning function of 360 security guard system
◆ Clean up the plug-in function (after scanning out 1, it is recommended to clean up the plug-in or the template.vbs in that emeditor directory, 5 and keep the plug-in 360 itself /Microsoft office/wmp recording component /adobe download component /Flash control).
◆ Clean up garbage (system junk files/Internet cache files/cache files for listening to music and watching videos/application junk files).
◆ Clean up traces (traces of surfing the Internet/using /windows/ using office software/watching videos/using other applications).
◆ Optimized acceleration (startup acceleration 20, system acceleration 3).
◆ System maintenance (routine system abnormal inspection and maintenance, computer outpatient problem form maintenance).
◆ Start acceleration (startup items/planned tasks/application software services/system key services).
Figure 15 QQ computer housekeeper or 360 which is better: 360 security guard computer cleaning function
QQ Computer Butler System Optimized Cleaning Function
◆ Clean up plug-ins (8 plug-ins were scanned, including 2 onenote buttons in Microsoft office/5 invalid shortcuts /IE toolbar).
◆ Clean up garbage (recycle bin/system garbage files/online cache files/cache files for listening to music and watching videos/other application garbage files/registry garbage).
◆ Clean up traces (traces of windows use/web browsing/browser search records/web page password saving/audio and video playback /office documents/traces of other applications).
◆ Acceleration of startup (5 1 problems affecting startup speed were found, including 24 forbidden items, 27 startup items, service items and task management).
◆ System acceleration (startup and shutdown acceleration/system stability/error handling optimization/file system optimization/network security and speed optimization/speed optimization).
◆ System maintenance (routine system abnormality inspection and maintenance).
Figure 16 QQ computer housekeeper or 360: QQ computer housekeeper system optimization function
Summary of this comparison: the two participating softwares are almost tied, and both sides have thoroughly cleaned up the traces of the system.
Which do you choose, 6QQ computer housekeeper or 360? Back to the top
Seven, QQ computer housekeeper and 360 network traffic monitoring function which is better?
Nowadays, many users are using 3G wireless Internet access, but at present, most operators have different traffic restrictions on 3G traffic of different packages, and the charges beyond the traffic are not cheap. Can 360 security guards and QQ computer butlers help users monitor network traffic?
Network monitoring function of 360 traffic firewall
◆ Manage the network speed (check the uploading and downloading speed of networking programs/limit the uploading speed).
◆ Network physical examination (to detect problems that may lead to network failure).
◆ Network speed protection (to protect the program from being downloaded).
◆ LAN protection (to prevent attacks from within the LAN).
◆ 3G assistant (traffic monitoring and over-current reminding, you can choose the traffic package/monthly traffic statistics chart according to the operator).
◆ Wireless routing anti-collision network reminder.
◆ Network speed test.
◆ Network connection (display the target address of the connection port of the current networking program machine).
◆ Suspended box (display instant upload and download speed /cpu and memory usage/total network traffic/fastest program/most cpu program/weather forecast).
Figure 17 QQ computer housekeeper or 360: 360 security guard traffic monitoring
QQ computer housekeeper network monitoring function
◆ Manage the network speed (check the uploading and downloading speed of networking programs/limit the uploading and downloading speed).
◆ Network connection (display the target address of the connection port of the current networking program machine).
◆ Network speed protection (protection programs will not be downloaded, which will affect intelligence/webpage priority/game priority/temporary protection).
◆ 3G assistant (traffic monitoring and overflow reminder, monthly traffic statistics chart).
◆ Network speed test.
◆ Suspended box (showing the instant upload and download speed).
Figure 18 QQ computer housekeeper or 360: QQ traffic monitoring
Summary of this comparison: QQ computer housekeeper has more powerful network speed management function, while 360 security guards have more comprehensive functions. In terms of pylons, 360 security guards provide more information.
Eight, QQ computer housekeeper and 360, which is better to add practical functions?
Other additional practical functions of 360 security guards
◆ 360 secure desktop (virtual desktop can quickly start many applications of desktop wallpaper).
◆ 360 mobile assistant (management assistant of Android phone).
◆ 360 bodyguards (strengthen system security, authenticate online shopping, bank website entrance).
◆ 360 power-saving assistant (to help users save electricity).
◆ 360 bedrooms are necessary (many people share broadband, so you can quickly know which user occupies a lot of bandwidth).
◆ Disconnect the first aid kit (local troubleshooting tool when Internet access is unavailable).
◆ Software uninstallation (according to the software installed by users, help users uninstall unnecessary software and analyze software personality).
◆ 360 performance physical examination (find out the reason why the computer is slow).
◆ 360 game optimizer (releasing resources such as memory speed for playing games).
◆ 360 computer experts (let professionals help you solve computer problems for free within a limited time).
◆ 360 file recovery (recovery of mistakenly deleted files).
◆ 360 Health Elf (to remind users to rest regularly to protect eyes and cervical vertebrae).
◆ 360 password security evaluator (evaluating password strength).
Other additional practical functions of QQ computer housekeeper
◆ Manage the right-click menu (system and IE right-click menu management).
◆ Property bodyguards (set the entrance of commonly used authentication websites to monitor the operating environment and prevent them from entering phishing websites)
◆ File security (create encrypted local storage space to protect users' private files from being stolen). .
◆ QQ security (check the security of QQ account).
◆ Stubborn Trojan nemesis (forcefully killing stubborn Troy).
◆ Expert assistance (ask experts to help you solve the computer fault charging matters).
◆ Installation Assistant (backup and recovery of drivers/software/personal data).
◆ Health assistant (to remind users to take regular breaks).
◆ Web game clinic (Web games can't display problem-solving tools such as unable to log in).
◆ Android management (management assistant of Android phone).
◆ QQ level acceleration (you can enjoy the privilege of level acceleration by logging into QQ account).
Summary of this comparison: the additional functions provided by the two participating softwares are practical, and the additional functions will increase with the update of the software. On the whole, the additional functions provided by 360 security guards are more practical.
9. Which is better, QQ computer housekeeper or 360, resource occupancy comparison test?
Test items: The author recorded the resource occupation of QQ Computer Manager 4.7 when it was idle (when it didn't run any other programs within 5 minutes after startup) and when it was scanning for viruses (dynamically).
In the dynamic test, the author selects 1 minute, 2 minutes, 3 minutes, 4 minutes and 5 minutes during the scanning period to record real-time data, and calculates their average values as the test results. Due to different computer configurations, this test does not represent the test results on all computers.
Figure 19 QQ computer housekeeper or 360 which is better: 360 security guards occupy resources when they are stationary.
Figure 20 Which is better, QQ computer housekeeper or 360: QQ computer housekeeper takes up resources when it is still.
In the static state, 360 security guards occupy 0-3% of CPU resources and about 37M of memory resources. The resource occupation of QQ computer housekeeper is 0-3% of CPU resources, and the memory resource is about 36M.
360 security guards resource occupation
Recording time
CPU utilization (%)
Memory usage (k)
1 min
25
147576
Two minutes
1 1
154856
3 minutes
10
176460
4 minutes
nine
18 1300
5 minutes
10
183436
Average
13
168725.6
QQ computer housekeeper resource occupation
Recording time
CPU utilization (%)
Memory usage (k)
1 min
17
373760
Two minutes
17
375552
3 minutes
19
394528
4 minutes
32
378552
5 minutes
33
388 128
Average
23.6
382 104
Under dynamic conditions, the average resource occupation of 360 security guards is CPU resource 13% and memory resource 168M. The resources occupied by QQ computer housekeeper are 23.6% of CPU resources and 382M of memory resources.
Summary of this comparison: From the test, we can see that the resources occupied by 360 security guards and QQ computer housekeeper are tied at rest, while the resources occupied by QQ computer housekeeper during dynamic test are not as good as those of 360 security guards, although they occupy relatively few resources.
abstract
As an old-fashioned security software, 360 Security Guard has comprehensive functions and is suitable for computer veterans. As a junior QQ computer housekeeper, Q is constantly moving closer to its predecessors, with comprehensive functions and simple use, which is suitable for computer beginners. In terms of system monitoring, 360 security guards are stronger, but in terms of virus killing, QQ computer housekeeper with four anti-virus engines is stronger. Radish and vegetables have their own tastes. What security AIDS are installed in readers' computers?