Fifty years tied Zhang Fei, thirty years tied Zhang Fei and Guan Yu, and was finally defeated by Liu (5)
The original text is: a general on the side, his eyes wide open, his beard and spear erect, and his flying horse shouted, "Don't go, Third Name!" " Yan Zhang Fei is here! "Lyu3 bu4 at the sight of this, abandon Gongsun Zan and fight Zhang Fei. Fly full of energy, hit Lu Bu. Even more than 50, regardless of the outcome. Seeing this, Yun Chang kowtowed and danced with a 82-pound dragon crescent moon blade to attack Lu Bu. Three horses are fighting with each other. When the battle reaches 30, Lu Bu cannot be defeated. Liu Xuande pulled out a double-edged sword and dashed at his yellow-maned horse to help stab him. These three surrounded Lu Bu. Kill people like hemp. The Eighth Route Army was stunned. Lu Bu blocked Liu Bei's face and stabbed him in vain. Liu Bei flashed. Lu Bu swung the angle, dragged the halberd backwards, and the flying horse returned. ......
This is the original description of the well-known "Three British Wars against Lu Bu". Although Zhang Fei was "tied for more than 50 consecutive battles." But it is conceivable that if Zhang Fei had the upper hand against Lyu3 bu4, how could Guan Yu help his brother? Visible Luo Guanzhong hinted that Zhang Fei was weaker than Lu Bu. Guan Yu must use the word "three Martin" when he goes to war. In thirty battles, Lu Bu cannot be defeated. "Luo Guanzhong used three words:" The war cannot be defeated ". In other words, Zhang Fei and Guan Yu had an advantage in the situation, but they could not turn their advantages into victory. As the saying goes, two fists are hard to defeat four hands, but Lu Bu can still be defeated in the face of the attack of two super-class military commanders, which shows that he deserves the first place. So I don't waste words anymore.
About Ma Chao:
A few lilies are flat and Zhang Fei (65)
The original text is very long, so I will list several paragraphs separately: Guan Ma Chao sent Zhang Fei out, but Zhang Fei closed it and wanted to swallow Ma Chao, so Liu Bei held back for three or five times. In the afternoon, Liu Bei saw that Ma Chao's troops were tired, so he chose 500 riders and followed Zhang Fei to Shimonoseki. . . . .
I can see that Ma Chao is a little tired, and Zhang Fei leaves early and returns late.
Then read the original text: look at the afternoon. Seeing that Ma Chao's troops were tired, Liu Bei chose 500 riders and followed Zhang Fei to Shimonoseki. When Ma Chao saw that Zhang Feijun had arrived, he looked at the gun and moved. Retreat is just a stone's throw away. Zhang Fei's army was tied to horses; Turn on the charger and come down one after another. Zhang Fei stood out with a gun and shouted, "Do you know Yan Zhang Yide?" Ma Chao said, "My family has been a prince for many years and I don't know a village man!" Zhang Fei was furious. Two horses at the same time, two guns at the same time About a hundred battles, regardless of the outcome. Liu Bei saw it and sighed, "What a tiger general!" Afraid of Zhang Fei's mistake, he sounded the golden bell order to retreat. The two generals will repay each other. Zhang Fei returned to the array, took a short rest from his horse, wrapped himself in a towel, mounted his horse without wearing a helmet, and went out to face Ma Chao. Super and destroy, the two fight again. Liu Bei was afraid that Zhang Fei would lose, so he went to Shimonoseki and went to the front. Seeing Zhang Fei and Ma Chao fighting more than 100 times, my spirit doubled. Xuande teaches to ring the golden bell and withdraw the army. The two will separate and return to the array. "
It can be seen that it is really close in actual combat. The original text reads: "I am afraid that Zhang Fei will lose, so I will call back." It can be seen that Zhang Fei is slightly inferior, and considering that Ma Chao's physical consumption before the war is slightly higher, it can be considered that Ma Chao is slightly stronger than Zhang Fei.
Of course, it is somewhat arbitrary to draw such a conclusion. So I will list the arguments again.
Eighty-nine were defeated by the ban, and twenty rounds were defeated by Zhang He (58)
The original text is: "Speak it out and point it at me. Follow Cao Cao, and it is forbidden to go out to meet the enemy. When two horses were fighting, they fought together and were defeated by the ban. Zhang He went out to meet the enemy, but he was also defeated in the battle of twenty miles. Li Tong rushed out to meet the enemy, and he fought bravely. After several rounds, he shot thomas lee's horse. . .
It can be seen that Ma Chao is obviously higher than Z Ryan.
Back to the twentieth Zhang Feiping and Zhang He (70)
The original text is: "I led 10,000 soldiers, 30 miles away from Langzhong, and met Zhang. The two armies dispersed and Zhang Fei went out together. After more than 20 minutes of fighting with guns, the troops suddenly shouted: I saw the flag of Shu soldiers behind the mountain, so I disturbed it. Zhang He didn't dare to fight, so he brought the horse back. "
The reason why Zhang He sent his horse back has nothing to do with the situation of one-on-one hit. After 20 rounds, the two were neck and neck.
Thirty or fifty Zhang Fei Ping Zhang He (70)
The original text is: "That night, Zhang He rode in the moonlight and led the army down from the mountain side to the front of the village. Looking at Zhang Fei's headlights and candles, he is drinking in his account. Zhang Hexian shouted first, and the drums started on the mountain, reaching directly. But I saw Zhang Fei sitting still. Zhang He suddenly rushed to the front, but it was a grass man who was shot down by him. When I hurried back to the horse, I was bombed by my account. A general took the lead, blocked the way, opened his eyes and sounded like a giant thunder: it was Zhang Fei. Jump out with a gun and take Zhang He straight. The two will fight in the firelight until 30-50. Zhang He only hoped that these two villages would come to save him. Unexpectedly, the reinforcements of Wei Yan and Tong Lei were defeated and the second village was taken. Zhang didn't see the rescuer coming, but he was helpless. He saw a sea of fire on the mountain, and Zhang Fei's rear army had captured the stockade. Zhang He lost all three villages and had to go to Wakouguan. "
It can be seen that Z Ryan should be at a psychological disadvantage in this one-on-one hit, but the two sides were tied.
It can be seen that it is not as easy for Zhang Fei to win a merger as Ma Chao.
Through indirect comparison with Zhang He, I think Ma Chao is better than Zhang Fei. Of course, considering that Zhang Fei is 9 years old, Ma Chao is slightly better than Zhang Fei.
About Zhang Fei, Guan Yu and Huang Zhong
Lu Bu pulls Ji Ling, such as Ju Zi (16).
The original text said, "Ji Ling dismounted and entered the village, only to find Liu Bei sitting in his tent. He was frightened and withdrew. I can't stay here. Lu Bu pulls forward, which seems to be childish. "
Lu Blagi Ling, just like an adult pulling a doll.
Zhang Fei didn't kill Ji Ling ten points (2 1).
The original text said, "When Liu Bei heard that Yuan Shu was coming, he led Guan Yu, Zhang Wei and 50,000 soldiers to meet the pioneer Ji Ling. Zhang Fei didn't speak, but took Ji Ling. When the battle failed, Zhang Fei shouted and stabbed Ji Ling under his horse, and the defeated army fled. "
Guan Yu 30 (14) tied Ji Ling (many friends may not believe it).
The original text said: "Ji Ling was furious and took Liu Bei directly. Guan Yu shouted, "Pi Fu, don't try to be brave! "War with JiLing. Thirty consecutive victories, regardless of the outcome. Ji Ling shouted "Don't rest", and Guan Yu called his horse back to the front and stood in front. "
Because they are alive > killed > dominant, we have reason to think that Lu Bu > Zhang Fei > Guan Yu.
Guan Yu's 100 games were tied. Huang Zhong (53 years old)
When Yun Chang saw a veteran coming out, he knew it was Huang Zhong. He released the word "swordsman of 500 schools", and the horizontal knife immediately asked, "Could it be Huang Zhong?" Zhong said, "If you know my name, how dare you invade our land!" Yunshang said, "I've come to get your head!" Then he took two horses. Fighting more than a hundred times, regardless of the outcome. Afraid of Huang Zhong's loss, Han Xuan rang the golden bell to retreat. Huang zhong accepted the army and entered the city. Yun Chang also withdrew from the army and went down to the village ten miles away from the city. I thought to myself, "veteran Huang Zhong really deserves his reputation: fighting a lily is seamless. I'll win with my back with a drag knife. "
Han Xuan's fear of Huang Zhong losing shows that Huang Zhong has at least a little inferiority complex. As for Guan Yu's evaluation of Huang Zhong, we can see that Huang Zhong and Guan Yu are very close in strength. Guan Gong can't win by routine, but by dragging a knife.
Guan Yu's two battles, Huang Zhong's combination of five or six, tied (53)
After breakfast the next day, I came to town to fight again. Han Xuan sat on the wall and told Huang Zhong to get out. Zhong led hundreds of riders to kill the suspension bridge, and then made horses with Yun Chang. Fighting fifty or sixty times again, regardless of the outcome, the two armies cheered in unison. The drums began to beat, and Yun Chang pulled the horse away. Huang Zhong is here. Yun Changfang heard a noise behind his head and wanted to cut it off with a knife. Looking back, I saw that Huang Zhong had been defeated in front of the horse and was thrown to the ground. Yun Chang hurried back to his horse, raised his knife with both hands and shouted, "I will spare your life!" Change horses and kill! " Huang Zhong quickly raised his horseshoe, flew on horseback, and abandoned his horse to enter the city. Xuan Jing asked. Zhong Yue said, "This horse has not been in battle for a long time, so it has lost something."
It can be seen that the two sides tied, and Huang Zhong's defeat was obviously related to horses.
Guan Yu and Huang Zhong fought for thirty rounds, and Huang Zhong cheated and lost, and shot Guan Yu's red tassel (53)
At dawn the next day, people reported that the clouds were fighting. Zhong led the troops out of the city. Yun Chang and Huang Zhong played for two days, and he was very worried. He is imposing and has made friends with Zhong Zhong. After less than 30 battles, loyalty and righteousness were defeated, and the clouds grew. Loyal to the grace of not killing yesterday, I couldn't bear to shoot it. I grabbed the knife and pulled the bow. There was a flash on the cloud, but there was no arrow. Clouds are long and rushing, loyal and empty, clouds are long and flashing, and there are no arrows; Just say that Huang Zhong won't shoot, don't worry. Near the suspension bridge, Huang Zhong drew an arrow on the bridge and drew a bow. The whistling arrow arrived, and it hit the root of Yunshang helmet.
This time, Huang Zhong was outstanding. This shows that the strength of the two sides is close, and it is impossible to tell the winner within at least 100 round.
Huang Zhong tied Xia in the 20th round (7 1).
Yuan was furious and suddenly took Huang Zhong away. Loyalty is about to shake the abyss to fight. The two generals handed over their horses and the battle lasted for more than 20 minutes. Suddenly, Cao Ying rang the golden bell of retreat. In a deep panic, he pulled his horse back and was killed by Zhong. Hui Yuan-Array asked Array's commander, "Why did you ring the golden bell?" He replied: "I saw several flags of Shu soldiers in the ravine. I was afraid that I was ambushed, so I called the general back." Yuan believed what he said, so he couldn't stick to it.
It can be seen that Xia and Huang Zhong are equal in strength.
Considering that Huang Zhong's age is obviously higher than others, we have reason to believe that Huang Zhong, Xia and Guan Yu are close in strength, but among them, Huang Zhong is definitely the first, while Xia and Guan Yu are similar (as for their level, I will discuss it later), and Zhang Fei beat Xia (3 1), which proves once again that Zhang Fei is better than Guan Yu.
With these two arguments, I think Zhang Fei is better than Guan Yu.
About a pound.
Guan Yu and Pound are even (74)
The original text is: Guan Yu cursed: "How can you measure a person?" ! It's a pity that my dragon sword beheaded your thief! "Riding a horse and dancing with a knife, come and get Pound. German wheel knife greets. There were more than a hundred battles between the two generals, and their spirit doubled. The two armies each looked silly. Wei Jun was afraid that Pound would fail and ordered the troops to retreat. Guan Ping was afraid that his father was old, so he rang the golden bell urgently.
Apart from this fight, I can't find a particularly useful record to directly or indirectly judge the level of force between Pound and Guan Yu. Considering Guan Yu's age, Pound can think that he is weaker than Guan Yu.
Some friends may mention Pound's achievements in the "Four Generals' Great Battle". I think this campaign reference is of little significance.
When Cao Cao was in Weiqiao, he knew Pound's bravery like the back of his hand and told his generals: "Pound was a brave general in Xiliang, and originally belonged to Ma Chao; Although today, according to Zhang Lu, it is not according to his mind. I want this person. You all have to fight slowly, weaken it, and then catch it. " Zhang He went out first, and after several wars, he withdrew. Xia also closed several wars. Huang Xu's "Three Five Wars" also retired. After the battle, Chu Xu fought more than 50 battles and retreated. Pound fought fearlessly against four generals.
It can be seen that the four generals all aimed at consuming Pound's physical strength and did not try their best.
About Chu Xu and Dian Wei
Next, I'll talk about Chu Xu, who has the most fights with the first-class military commanders among the three countries, so the analysis of Chu Xu is one of the focuses of this article.
Chu Xu tied Dian Wei for hundreds of rounds (12).
Wei was furious and fought with two halberds. From morning till night, the two men won or lost, and each had less rest. Soon, strong men will fight again, and so will Dian Wei. Fighting until dusk, everyone stopped for lack of horses.
In addition, I can't find any record of Dian Wei fighting with a first-class military commander. The two sides played for a long time, but they didn't win the game. It can be seen that the two are really close. It is speculated that Dian Wei may be older than Chu Xu, so he boldly ranked Chu Xu behind Dian Wei, but the two places are close.
Chu Xu tied with Huang Xu in 50 rounds (14).
The original text is: Cao Cao looked at the horse and was secretly surprised to see Huang Xu magnificent; Then let Chu Xu become a horse and Huang Xu. Knives and axes intersect, and there are more than 50 battles, regardless of victory or defeat. Cao Cao immediately sounded the golden bell to retreat and called the ministers to discuss: "Yang Feng and Han Xian are not sincere enough; Huang Xu is really a good soldier. I can't bear to combine it with strength, so I have to recruit it in a planned way. "
From the original text, Cao Cao is afraid that Chu Xu will hurt Huang Xu, which shows that Chu Xu has an advantage over Huang Xu.
Chu Xu tied Ma Chao in every shot (59)
Chu Xu came out with a horse and a knife before he finished. Ma Chao picked up his gun and began to fight. There have been more than a hundred fights, and the outcome is regardless. When the horse was tired, he returned to the army, changed horses and went out again. Fighting more than a hundred times, regardless of the outcome. Chu Xu was furious, flew back to the front, took off his armor, was stiff all over, raised his knife naked, turned over and mounted his horse, and engaged Ma Chao. The two armies are terrible. The two men fought for more than 30 times, and Chu raised a knife to cut Ma Chao. Super flash, a shot straight to Chu's heart. Chu abandoned the knife and seized the gun. Two men were riding horses fighting for guns. Xu was strong, snapped, broke the gun, took half a piece from each and hit the horse. Cao Cao was afraid of Chu's mistake, so he ordered Xia and Cao Hong to attack together.
This movement is very fierce, but from the initial analysis, we can see that Chu Xu is at a disadvantage. There are two reasons. First, the original text said, "Chu raised a knife to cut Ma Chao. Super flash, a shot straight to Chu's heart. Chu abandoned the knife and seized the gun. Two men are fighting for guns on horseback. " Thus, Ma Chao can dodge Chu Xu's attack, but Chu Xu has no choice but to abandon his sword and carry a gun in the face of Ma Chao's attack. Secondly, Cao Cao was afraid that Chu Xu would fail in the war, which proved that Chu Xu was at a disadvantage.
It can be seen that Ma Chao is better than Chu Xu, but it takes hundreds of rounds to decide the outcome.
It is not easy to distinguish between Zhang Fei and Chu Xu, because both of them have fought against Ma Chao hundreds of times. However, if we really want to analyze it, the best proof is Lu Bu.
Lu Bu beat Chu Xu in the 20th round (12).
The original text is: (Lu Bu) led the troops out of the battle and cursed with a halberd. Chu Xu came out. Twenty times, it's a tie. Cao Cao said, "Lu Bu can't win alone." Then send Dian Wei to help, and the two will attack; On the left and summer, on the right Li Dian and come together. Six members will attack Lu Bu together.
Zhang Fei played 50 rounds with Lu Bu and Guan Yu, and Chu Xu played 20 rounds. Therefore, Zhang Fei is slightly better than Chu Xu.
Of course, Zhang Fei and Lu Bu met again.
Zhang Fei and Lily Ping Lu Bu (16)
The original text said, "Why did Brother lead his troops here?" Bu Zhi scolded, "I shot a halberd at the gate of the shaft and saved you. Why did you take my horse? " Liu Bei said, "I don't want to ride my brother's horse because I am short of horses." Bu said, "You let Zhang Fei take my 150 good horses, and you still don't admit it!" Zhang Fei pulled out his gun and said, "I took your good horse! What are you doing today? " "Ring-eyed thief! You despise me again and again! " Fei said, "If I take your horse, you will be annoyed. If I take my brother Xuzhou, you will not say anything!" Butingji went out to fight Zhang Fei in Malay and flew to meet the enemy with a gun. The two men fought more than a hundred times, and there was no victory or defeat. Liu Bei was afraid of negligence, so he rang the golden bell and returned to the city.
Liu Bei was afraid that Zhang Fei would lose, so Zhang Fei was at a disadvantage. However, Chu Xu and Zhang Fei challenged Lyu3 bu4 twice, both during Lyu3 bu4' s stay in Xuzhou, which shows that Zhang Fei is superior to Chu Xu.
Here, I want to say that although Zhang Fei and Lu Bu played 100 round, I think this is the result of Lu Bu's physical decline. There are two reasons: first, Lu Bu is ten years old and Zhang Fei is ten years old. In the battle of Tiger Prison, Lu Bu should be at the peak, but at this moment, Lu Bu's aging is definitely declining. Secondly, the original text clearly explains: Bu Yue: "I have a red rabbit horse, and I am afraid to cross the water like a flat ground!" It was a day when my wife and I drank wine. Because of the harm of wine color, I described it as a decrease in sales. One day, I said to myself in the mirror, "I was hurt by wine and color!" " Starting today, you should quit. "So he ordered the whole city to be on alert, but all the drinkers were beheaded.
Lyu3 bu4 excessive debauchery, physical fitness plummeted.
There is another passage: Cao Bing at the gate of the city looked at the white flag on the city and desperately attacked the city. But he must go to the enemy himself. From Pingming to Japan and China, Cao Bing retreated slightly. Bu Shao rested in the gatehouse and fell asleep in the chair. Song Xian drove around, stole his painting halberd first, and then started work with Xu Wei to tie Lu Bu's rope tightly.
My body was hollowed out and I fell asleep sitting down.
There are three military commanders. This is the most important part of this paper. These three military commanders are Zhao Yun, Yan Liang and Wen Chou. Personally, I think the force of these three military commanders has been misunderstood.
About Zhao Yun
Fifty or sixty paintings revenge (7)
The original text is: "Wen Chou pulled the spear. Suddenly, a young general appeared on the left side of the grass slope. Pegasus armed, straight for Wen Chou. Gongsun Zan went up the mountain to see the young man: eight feet long, heavy eyebrows, wide face and heavy weight, commanding, fighting Wen Chou for fifty or sixty years, and the outcome was not divided. Zan men to save the army, Wen dial the horse back to the domain. The boy didn't chase. Zan hurried down the slope and asked the boy's name. The boy leaned down and replied, "One is Changshan. His surname is Zhao, Ming Yun and Zi Long. "
The article focuses on the word "juvenile". Visible is not at its peak, and Wen Chou is a contemporary star, so that the two are evenly matched, but Zhao is better than Wen Chou.
Thirty rounds of Chu (3 1)
Cao Cao was furious and taught Chu Xu to go to war. Behind Liu Bei, Zhao Tingyun came out with a gun. Whatever the outcome, the two generals will meet 30 times. Sudden earthquake, southeast corner, cloud conflict; In the southwest corner, Zhang Fei led the army into conflict. Cover and kill three places together Cao Jun came from far away, exhausted and unable to reach, and left with a big failure. Xuande returned to camp victorious.
This is a draw, but considering that there are only 30 rounds. Therefore, it is considered that this campaign proves that there is little difference between the two, but it cannot be considered that the level of the two is particularly close.
Thirty defeats and Zhang defeats (3 1)
The original text is: "Xuande is overjoyed. Yun Zongma, armed with a gun, left the rear team and came to the former army to fight alone. Tai and Yun fought for more than 30 times, and the horse was defeated. The cloud took advantage of the situation to kill, but it was guarded by soldiers and the road was narrow. "
According to the example of the battle between Zhang Fei and Zhang He, we know that Zhao is only one year older than Zhang Fei and Zhao is stronger than Zhang Fei.
As for D and Zhao Yun, I think:
Interested friends will find that Zhao Yun's 30-round defeat was based on the draw of Chu Xu, a first-class military commander. Ma Chao defeated Zhang He in the 20th round, just after defeating a second-rate military commander. It can be seen that Zhao Yun's physical exertion is greater than Ma Chao's, so I think this can make up for the disadvantage of 10 round.
Zhao Yun defeated Li Dian in ten rounds (Li Dian couldn't beat the enemy) (36)
The original text is: two circles, Zhao Yun immediately called his generals to answer. Coss ordered Li Dian to go out and confront Zhao Yun. After about a dozen battles, Li Dian expected the enemy to fail and brought the horse back. Cloud long longitudinal horse chase, the two wings of the army volley, and then each retreat.
Yu Jin and Li Dian are both second-rate military commanders. 1989 Ma Chao's failure directly defeated Yujin, and Zhao Yun's cooperation in the past ten years made Li Dian unable to defeat the enemy (not yet defeated). Therefore, this time I think Ma Chao has a slight advantage.
To sum up, I think Zhao Yun and Ma Chao are very close in strength. It can be considered as Ma Chao > = Zhao Yun.
Zhao Yun scared Huang Xu's jaw and pulled out his horse (7 1).
The original text is: "Yun was furious and shot his horse suddenly, stabbing Jiao Bing to death. Kill the rest of the soldiers, straight to Beishan, see Zhang He, two people surrounded by Huang Zhong, sergeant trapped for a long time. Cloud let out a cry and galloped into the tight encirclement, like nobody's business. Gun body, if dancing pear flower; Black and white is like falling snow. Zhang He was too frightened to meet each other. Cloud to save Huang Zhong, fight and go; No matter where we go, no one dares to stop us.
This is a good example. You know, it was Huang Xu who dared to challenge Guan Yu, and it was Zhang He who drew Chu Xu in fifty rounds. Of course, it is important to consider the existence of Huang Zhong.
About Yan Liang.
No three chop Song Xian (25)
A divided Xu Wei (25)
Twenty countries defeated Huang Xu, and the generals were frightened (25) (very important)
The original text is: "Yan Liang's horizontal knife immediately went under the door; Seeing the arrival of Song Xian, he gave him good wine and rode to meet him. The battle was divided, the sword fell, and Song Xian beheaded. Cao Cao was startled and said, "What a brave general!" Xu Wei said, "I am willing to revenge for killing my companion! "Damn, it worked. Then he got on the horse, gun in hand, strode out of the battlefield, cursing Yan Liang. Liang Geng stopped talking, handed the horse, picked up the first knife, and cut Xu Wei under the horse. Cao Cao said, "Who dares to be now?" Huang Xu answered, and Yan Liang played 20 times, all lost to this array. These generals are Li Ran. Cao Cao withdrew his troops, and Liang also led them back. "Huang Xu answer out, Yan Liang twenty, lost in this array. These generals are Li Ran. Cao Cao withdrew his troops, and Liang also led them back.
Cao Cao was very depressed when he saw that he had beheaded two generals in a row. Cheng Yu said, "One man can defeat Yan Liang." Fuck, ask who it is. Yu said: "This is necessary." Cao Cao said, "I'm afraid he'll leave when he gets his grades." Yu Yue said, "If Liu Bei were here, he would vote for Yuan Shao. If Yun Chang breaks Yuan Shao's soldiers today, Shao will suspect Liu Bei and kill him. If you are ready to die, will Yunchang be safe? "
There are two points to explain this time.
First: What is the concept of beating Huang Xu in the 20th round?
Just now, I mentioned a war example: Chu Xu drew Huang Xu in the 50th round (14), which shows that Yan Liang is obviously superior to Chu Xu.
Second: General Li Ran was used at the end of the first paragraph of the original text, and Cheng Yu recommended an enemy in the second paragraph. Thus, summer should be inferior to Guan Yu.
When he wanted to ask questions under the cover of the people, he was beheaded (25)
The original text is "Guan Yu rode his horse backwards with dragon sword, and ran down the mountain with wide eyes and straight eyebrows. Hebei army is like stormy waves, and Guan Gong is heading for Yan Liang. Yan Liang, under the cover, saw Guan Yu coming and wanted to ask, Guan Yu reacted quickly and ran to the front; Yan Liang was caught off guard and was stabbed by Yun Chang. "
Personally, this war example is the biggest injustice in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms.
I think a netizen analyzed it very well. Let me quote him to explain.
The original text analyzed by netizens is: "① Let's say that Yan Liang was killed for a reason, and there is indeed a wrong side. Let's analyze several problems together.
Before killing Liang. In chapter 25 of the book, there is such a dialogue-Cao Cao was depressed when he saw two generals lined up. Cheng Yu said, "One man can defeat Yan Liang." ..... Yu said, "It is necessary to go." Cao Cao said, "I'm afraid he'll leave when he gets his grades." Yu Yue said, "If Liu Bei were here, he would vote for Yuan Shao. If Yun Chang breaks Yuan Shao's soldiers today, Shao will suspect Liu Bei and kill him. If you are ready to die, will Yunchang be safe? " Many people quoted this dialogue as evidence that Guan Yu was stronger than Yan Liang. Although the result of this war was indeed that Yan Liang was beheaded, this was not the original intention of Cheng Yu's remarks. Otherwise, why didn't he just say "one man can beat Yan Liang"? Looking up the Chinese dictionary, the enemy can be interpreted as "confrontation with equal strength", so Cheng Yu's remarks mean that only Guan Gong's force (excluding other generals in Cao Ying) can compete with Yan Liang, or Guan Gong's force can compete with Yan Liang. Cheng Yu said that this passage is based on fairness and one-on-one hit between the two, not an attack. As for Cao Cao's idea of "fearing that he will pursue political achievements", it is only speculation and worry. It was not before the war that Cao Cao decided that Guan Yu would win. Robben said this more clearly: "Why not merge the two powers instead?" Reuse if you win. If you lose, you will be in doubt. "
There is still a passage in the book that should be paid enough attention to-Guan Gong said, "Let me see." ..... Cao Cao led Guan Yu to the Tushan to watch ... Guan Yu said, "In my opinion, it's like a dog's ear!" ..... Guan Yu lifted up his eyes and said to Cao Cao, "I see Yan Liang as a poster!" ..... Guan Yu got up and said, "Although I have no talent, I am willing to go to the army to take my head and give it to the Prime Minister." Why didn't Guan Yu just go one-on-one and "show people"? This passage actually reveals two meanings: first, it shows that Guan Yu is worthy of being a general with both wisdom and courage. Before going to war, he looked up at the enemy and knew himself; Secondly, it shows that Guan Yu has made a plan to defeat the enemy with confidence through observation, otherwise he would not dare to release his grandiloquence: "Native Wagou"-chickens and dogs carved with clay tiles, waste; "Selling the head by inserting the standard"-selling the head by inserting the standard, fool. Facing Yan Liang and his 100,000-strong army, Guan Yu didn't want to bother to fight one-on-one. What he wants is how to "go to the army to take the head and offer it to the prime minister" as soon as possible.
. Appreciate Robben first, not as evidence, for your reference and comparison. See Volume 5, Cloud Long Riding and Stabbing Yan Liang: "Gong mounted his horse upside down by dragon sword, ran down the dirt mountain, took off his helmet and put it in front of the saddle. He opened his eyes and straightened his eyebrows and came to the front. When the Hebei army saw it, the soldiers split into two ways, making way, and the people rushed forward. Yan Liang saw Guan Yu coming under the cover of the people, and just wanted to ask him, the horse was near. Cloud long hand, a knife to cut Yan Liang under the horse. ..... Yun Zhang dismounted and beheaded Yan Liang. ... flew on the horse and went out with a knife, as if in no man's land. " Is this as obvious as described in the one-on-one hit book? "Take off your helmet and put it in front of the saddle"-"Give way"-"Just want to ask" all indicate that this is a raid! Even better, Robben annotated this passage for fear that readers could not understand it: "It turns out that when Yan Liang resigned from Yuan Shao, Liu Xuande secretly told him,' I have a younger brother named Guan Yunchang, who is nine feet five inches long and must be one foot eight inches long, with a face as heavy as a jujube ... Make a dragon sword ... If I see him, I can teach him to come quickly. So when Yan Liang saw Guan Yu coming, he only knew that he had come to defect, and was not prepared to meet them, so he was beheaded by Guan Yu. "In addition, a hymn tells the mystery:" ... the hero died because of Xuande's departure. "
Looking at Mao Ben again, we can see in the twentieth time: "Gong got on the horse in high spirits and ran backwards down the hill with dragon sword. The phoenix eye is wide open, the silkworm eyebrow is straight, and it goes straight at each other. Hebei army is like stormy waves, and Guan Gong is heading for Yan Liang. Yan Liang was under cover when he saw Guan Yu rushing in, but when he wanted to ask questions, Guan Yu rushed to the front. Yan Liang caught off guard and was stabbed by Yun Chang. Dismounted abruptly, cut off Yan Liang's head, ... flew on the horse, took the knife like nobody's business, and went out. " In order to further highlight Guan Yu's bravery, Mao Ben seems to have omitted some descriptive words, but after careful analysis, we can also see some clues: First of all, Guan Gong's broadsword was turned backwards, paralyzing Yan Liang. If he is going to fight one-on-one or charge the array, there is no reason why he can hold the blade in one hand and rush down the bit; Secondly, if the Hebei army deliberately blocked, there would be no scene of waves breaking (divided into two sides), either surrounded by layers or scattered; Third, "when you want to ask" can also explain the problem. Yan Liang simply regarded Guan Yu as an enemy and was completely unprepared for the battle. So what is Yan Liang going to ask? I think it is most likely to ask Guan Yu's name, is it Guan Yu? From the dialogue between Yuan Shao and Liu Bei before the war, we can realize that "the second brother doesn't know the sound consumption, and his wife and children are trapped in Cao Cao". I guess Liu Bei may have described Guan Yu's appearance to Yuan Shao and Yan Liang, but it is not clear whether he can "secretly tell" Yan Liang anything like Robben. Finally, the word "thorn" is also worth pondering. Killing the enemy with a broadsword does not require common actions such as chopping, but stabbing! As we all know, Jing Ke, Yao Li and Zhuan Xu were famous assassins in ancient times. When they assassinated, they all took a surprise approach. Here, Guan Yu killed Yan Liang with a tattoo, which was also a surprise. Whether this war was a surprise attack or a fair one-on-one fight is obvious to all, and everyone should be able to draw a normal judgment. So can this world war I effectively reflect Guan Yu's force? Can you fully explain that Guan Yu's force is higher than Yan Liang's? The deceased has grown up! Yan Liang's sorrow and injustice are reflected here.
Incidentally, in Mao Ben, there is a saying that "a red rabbit is faster than a horse", but I think Guan Yu killed Yan Liang mainly by his ingenuity, courage and the use of Yan Liang's paralyzing thought. If Guan Yu rode an ordinary horse, Yan Liang would still "ask questions" and Guan Yunchang's Qinglong Dao would still become a butcher's knife.
So I think the battle between Guan Yu and Yan Liang is an invalid example.
About Wen Chou.
Sixty or seventy rounds tied with Zhao Yun (7)
In this campaign alone, I knew that Wen Chou was a superb military commander, but his strength should be slightly inferior to that of Zhao Yun.
The arrow shot Zhang Liao and was cut down by Guan Yu (26).
The original text is: "Zhang Liao and Huang Xu flew out together and shouted:" Wen Chou, stop! " Wen Chou looked back and saw that two generals had caught up with him, so he held down the iron gun, pulled out his bow and arrow, and shot directly at Zhang Liao. Huang Xu shouted, "Thieves will stop shooting arrows!" Zhang Liao ducked his head, and an arrow hit the helmet and the tassel. Liao struggled to catch up, sat on his horse and was shot in the cheek by an arrow from Wenchou. The horse fell to his knees, and Zhang Liao landed. When Wen Chou came back from his horse, Huang Xu turned his axe and stopped fighting. I saw Wen Chou's army coming behind, but the enemy couldn't beat him, so he pulled out his horse and came back. Wenchou came along the river. Suddenly, I saw more than ten people riding horses and waving flags. A general came with a knife in his head. It's Guan Yunchang. He shouted, "Thieves will stop! "Wen Chou and the horse, war is not trinity, Wen Chou timid, dial the horse and walk around the river. Guan Yu galloped to catch up with Wen Chou and dismounted Wen Chou with a knife in the back of his head. On the mound, Cao Cao saw Guan Yu cut down Wen Chou, so he led his troops to kill him. Most of the Hebei army fell into the water, and the grain, grass and horses were still recaptured by Cao Cao. "
It can be concluded from the original text that Wen Chou's martial arts is better than Zhang Liao's. As for being hacked to death by Guan Yu, it was because his companion was killed, he didn't know the situation, and his inner fear led to the same tragic result as Yan Liang. Of course, some friends may think that there is no head-on killing in this campaign, just shooting arrows, which is of little reference significance. Even so, after knowing what level Zhao Yun is, you can guess what level Wen Chou is.
As mentioned above, from the analysis of the battle between Zhao Yun and Wen Chou, we can draw the conclusion that Wen Chou is weaker than Zhao Yun. Because through Huang Xu, we know that Yan Liang is obviously higher than Chu Xu, and then we will consider Ma Chao. The record of Zhao Yun's meeting shows that Yan Liang's position is higher than that of Ma Yun.
Considering Lu Bu's invincible record, Yan Liang is second only to Lu Bu.
About General Wu Dong.
Taishi Ci draws Zhang Liao 70-80 (53)
Sun Ce tied with Taishi Ci in 50 rounds (15).
I also know that Zhang Liao drew Zhang He in forty or fifty rounds (30)
It can be seen that Taishi Ci, Sun Ce, Zhang He and Zhang Liao are at the same level, and it is hopeless to be selected into the top ten, so I won't go into details.
As for Gan Ning, he has never confronted a first-class military commander, and his strength is hard to estimate.
At the end of the article, I will tell some examples that I personally think are invalid.
Zhang Fei stabbed Chu Xu in the shoulder (below) 72
Chu Xu was drunk and in poor health.
Guan Yu defeated (seduced) Xia Houdun more than ten times (22)
Guan Yu killed Huang Xu and Chu Xu (22).
Xia Houdun, Huang Xu and Chu Xu are all in a state of luring the enemy, which is invalid.
Guan Yu tied Huang Xu in eighty rounds (76)
The original explanation is very clear. Because Guan Gong was injured by an arrow, he was "weak in his right arm". How can he play with a 82-pound dragon crescent moon blade? Invalid, not an example of Guan Yu being tainted.
Ma Chao defeated Cao Hong 40-50 (58) (Cao Hong laid down his life)
The background of this meeting is that Cao Hong fought to the death with Ma Chao in order to protect Cao Cao. On the contrary, Ma Chao was better than Jin, Zhang He and Li Tong, and pursued Cao Cao. Originally, their physical strength has been greatly consumed, and the purpose of his battle is to get rid of Cao Hong and catch up with Cao Cao, so I think this example is meaningless. Invalid.
To sum up, the top ten can be concluded as follows: Lu Bu, Yan Liang, Ma Chao, Zhao Yun, Wen Chou, Zhang Fei, Huang Zhong, Guan Yu, Dian Wei and Chu Xu.
Author: Shao Gong
Link:/question/20236440/answer/38868992
Source: Zhihu.