What do traders think of the phrase "trading is being a man"?
A complete sentence is "character determines fate, and trading is being a man." How did this sentence come true for all of you? Don't discuss the influence of personality on other industries, just talk about trading (futures, foreign exchange stocks, etc. )
Details of the problem:
First of all, thank you for your answers, mainly about the influence of different personalities on the transaction.
Please talk about the influence of different personalities on transactions. For example, do timid people like to be light-handed? Do radical and greedy people love heavy positions? People who lie and get lucky don't like stop loss? People who are impatient are more resistant to long-term trading? Do people who are not objective love bargain hunting?
For example, two people, chestnut and AB, get a stable and profitable trading system at the same time and make the same variety, but after the same time, the profit and loss results are different. Does it mean that personality has a great influence on trading? Does it mean that personality determines the upper and lower limits of trading?
Why do two apprentices taught by one master have different profit levels? Teaching is the same, but people are different.
The above does not include programmed transactions, only manual transactions are discussed.
Please feel free to give me your suggestions. If there is anything wrong with me, please point it out and refuse personal attacks and wrangling.
Thank you. Good luck.
There is no right or wrong question, and there is no standard answer. Everyone has a different understanding of the transaction, and it is normal to give different answers. Finally, it ends with a sentence: "The staff sergeant listens to it and the diligent person does it. Sergeant heard you. If he survived, the corporal laughed at it, but it was not enough to laugh "-from Lao Tzu's Tao Te Ching.
About the answer-Liu Da, in this business, is destiny takes a hand.
I think there is some truth in these two sentences. First, it is said that personality determines fate. For example, the subject said that people who are soft and radical may have different control over their positions. For example, acute temperament and chronic temperament have different choices for the operation cycle. Some personality traits are innate and difficult to change after tomorrow. In this respect, it is best not to go against your own nature, and to find a trading method that suits you is the most suitable for you.
The latter sentence says that trading is being a man. In fact, a friend said that everything is like this to a certain extent. But we may be low-level and have no strong experience. Considering that many senior experts have similar opinions, I think they may not be talking casually.
Say something simple. For example, testing whether a person is trustworthy. If it is determined that a trader is purely mechanized, subjective judgment should be abandoned. When he uses a mechanical system, it is equivalent to entrusting a trading decision-making power to the trading system. Then, if he can't bear the pressure and doesn't trust the system in the follow-up practical work, he will stop the work of the system forcibly, or interfere with or modify the decision of the system, which means that he has violated his promise.
For example, if you trust a certain trading idea (Tao) and express this idea in a system, the system is the embodiment of Tao. 100% practice this system is the way. If you are worried that the floating profit will shrink, or you don't want to see the floating loss expand (before the stop loss line is triggered), you will intervene in the system operation. This shows that immediate interests are more important to him than long-term, fundamental and macroscopic Tao.
For another example, whether a person is modest, obedient and persuasive, or conceited, arrogant and stubborn can also be seen from his trading behavior. Some people refuse to admit defeat to the market even if they lose a lot, and they don't admit that they are insignificant as a member of the market. Should obey the market. But standing on the opposite side of the market, blaming the market and talking to yourself. Like brain cells popping out of the brain.
Some traders, after losing money, will study hard and put down their posture. Although some traders have been losing money, they look down on everyone. Buffett is not in his eyes and never admits his mistake. Everything is set by the market. Such people, in other aspects of life, often can't bear the responsibility.
Soros said: The most important thing is character. Financial speculation needs to take great risks, and immoral people are unwilling to take risks. Such people are not suitable for high-risk speculation.
Anyone who engages in risky business but can't face the consequences is not a good player. In the team, the investment style can be completely different, but the character must be reliable.
About the answer-Lu Junhua, look at the bones and mark the way ...
It should be said that the way of trading is related to the way of being a man, but it is not necessarily related to your usual sense of good or bad. A successful trader is not necessarily a moral model in real life, but his insight into human nature and self-awareness must be sufficient. He is well aware of his position in the market, knowing what to do, what not to do, why to do it, when to do it, and he should do it.
In a word, this is a kind of social ability, that is, the way to survive in your circle and the way to advance and retreat between people. This viability is equally important in the trading world. How do you deal with the market? Know that you are advancing, know that you are retreating! Don't try to dominate the market, don't blindly succumb to the market, and don't be so inferior. Your relationship with the market is not a master and a slave, but a harmonious relationship with it.
Almost every market participant pretends to be a predator, but often ignores that he is also a prey in the eyes of other predators. Even if you are as fierce as liger, if you are targeted by a group of jackals, you can't run away. As for those scattered people who are waiting to be slaughtered like cattle and sheep, they should follow such a way of life, so they should first make clear their own position, know their position in this world, find their own survival strategy according to their various conditions, and how to preserve their strength. How do big coffees hide their strength? How to give full play to your advantages? How to prevent your personality defects from causing devastating damage to your account? How about ... Anyway ... Please feel free to reflect. Am I doing the right thing? Is there a better way? Constantly questioning and proving, constantly breaking through, surpassing yourself, and achieving the road of being a master ... The more you progress, the more the glorious side of your humanity can exert its incredible power.
As for the trading system, probability statistics, fund management and so on mentioned in other replies, I think they are all basic technical things. Needless to say, as long as you have done business seriously for several years. Of course, those are also important, but those in the process of trading belong to the category of primary schools. The theme of this topic is to discuss the realm after going to college, not to assume that you have passed that level. If you stay at that stage forever, your greatest achievement will only be to become a robot for counting money ... Then you will never understand why trading is a human state of mind, not a question of who is taller or who is lower, but that two lives are not at the same frequency at all, just like summer insects are speechless and belong to a state of being unable to communicate.
If trading, including any other industry, is only based on how much money is earned, what's the point of trading? What's the meaning of life? I believe that no successful trader will say that he got nothing but wealth in the transaction ... According to the topic owner's own statement, you should improve the basic part and temporarily put aside the relationship between trading and being a man ... It's the first time to answer questions seriously online, so thank you for seeing this, and then please feel free to spray ... Oh, I almost forgot, the picture above! Rudder 20 15.08. 16 Reply to the editor of Mr. Yu An to update the rudder. I find it takes a long time to answer such a long question. I finally know what kind of experience it is. Due to different trading concepts and different trading levels, unclear expression will cause misunderstanding. ! ! Please pay attention! ! ! Please pay attention! ! ! The following reply is based on the experience of practicing and trading. Please don't think I am a master trader, I am a senior loser! ! ! Because trading is just a way for me to temper my mind and a lesson on my spiritual path. In my daily life now, I watch the market for no more than 30 minutes on average every day (I am in foreign exchange, and I keep the market for 5*24 hours). Should 30 minutes be less? ), because it is very limited to improve one's mind through trading. Even if trading is difficult, it still belongs to the category of secular law and can only be regarded as the basis of practice. I just keep doing it to earn some food expenses. I'm still an ordinary child, and I still have to eat. There is a background in front, back to the topic: I was once obsessed with trading two years ago. It took me two years to give all the 65,438+10,000 yuan my parents gave me, and then I went to work happily ... During that time, my family, friends and relatives joked or bluntly said that I was lazy, afraid of hardship and fatigue, and did nothing. As long as people who have been trading for several years know how much to pay and how much to bear.
After many confrontations and refutations with them, I finally cleared myself. I said that the profession of trading belongs to mental workers other than manual workers and mental workers. I work with my heart and willpower, so you can't see it. As a result, they only ask you where your labor income is. I suddenly became incoherent. This, this, this is a special profession that only asks about cultivation and does not ask about harvest. One day, the market will pay me more than all of you, and then grab the door in everyone's ridicule ... Today, I still think it is appropriate for me to define traders as diligent workers, so you ask how to transfer from primary school to university? I think it is necessary to change the transaction from mental work to mental work. If you always stay in the brain's thinking logic level to guide trading, such as being entangled in specific opening and closing positions, subjective price forecasting, and constantly complicated trading rules in pursuit of perfection, I think they all belong to the primary school stage. What is the specific state of trading behavior in the university stage? According to the information I have read, I think the closest ones are Ghost of Wall Street and Crowe's Talking about Investment Strategy, and then I guess the big brother on the island. There is a question and answer post about killing people in the K-line. No matter whether you have seen it or not, please make up the lessons yourself, so you won't be wordy. I don't have much energy to talk about these specific operational details. The technical level is really not that important. There is no need to copy other people's things at all. As long as the concept is right, there can be countless trading systems. And they all work well. Each participant's market is unique. You're dealing in a market that belongs only to you. It is the knowledge that you and Mr. Market reached at a certain time and space, and no one can take it away. As for how to achieve this state, it takes time to accumulate and you work hard. There is no quick solution in ten days. Even an epiphany is based on gradual cultivation in previous years. Was Newton the only person in the world who was hit by an apple? Trading is an act. Successful trading means having a successful behavior pattern, not daydreaming with your head. The focus of practice is to do things. It doesn't matter even if you don't know the relevant theories, just like you don't know the professional knowledge of automobiles, it won't affect you to become a good driver. Of course, it is better to combine knowledge with practice. You just have to keep doing it, keep summing up, keep reflecting, and keep going beyond it. There is no right or wrong in doing this, but it has produced different results. This produced such a result, and that also produced such a result. As long as we sum up all the results, how can we do it better? Keep repeating this pattern and you will naturally succeed. When you look down one day, you will find that you are already at the top of the mountain ... all by yourself, others can't help you ... In this process, you will have your own unique theoretical ideas, not just what is said in books. If you are a conscientious person and have a good writing skills, record this successful mental journey.
Zoom in, what is the best opening mode for successful trading? Send us Hua Yan's six-character mantra of Daming as the end: Listening, appreciating, accepting, respecting, cherishing and tolerating this mantra is more than enough for both business and life. The communication between the three worlds is unimpeded. Please remember and hold it forever and apply it to all aspects of life. It's incredible! ! ! Limited by energy, I didn't answer this question, so I smiled. I wish everyone peace and comfort. ...
About the answer-He Ziyin
People live in truth and freedom for beauty. Who can embrace the different personalities of the world more openly has a great influence on transactions, and it is not only a transaction, but also reflected in all aspects of daily life. The different personality cases listed by the subject are all summaries of the actual situation, and there is no need to add them, which is basically a performance. Personality and humanity are two concepts. Different personalities will affect trading strategies, including long and short, fast and slow, but there is no difference between good and bad. Transactions with various cycles and frequencies are good as long as they can ensure stable profits. There may be friends who define good or bad by the level of income, but income is the embodiment of ability and has nothing to do with cycle and frequency. Moreover, this ability is not a measure of a person's character or humanity. I wonder if different human nature has any influence on the transaction. Human nature can be simply divided into good and evil. For example, a team wants to sit on a target. In the process of opening positions, pulling up and shipping, it is necessary to lure ordinary investors to follow suit. Maybe the team members are good people, but the operation method is to pit retail investors and let them make a profit. Do you think this is good or evil? This is the essence of work, right? A vicious and treacherous person must not make money in trading. No, he probably earns more than the average person. People can only comfort themselves with a psychological hint-it won't last long, or the money earned from the transaction has been spent elsewhere, and it will be paid back sooner or later, and so on. But these sincerity have nothing to do with you. "Character decides fate" can't be fully understood like this. Personality affects the process, and the result is not entirely determined by personality, at least there is time and luck. Doing business is being a man. What is life? What we usually understand is to be a good person, to be strict with ourselves in all aspects and to abide by public order and good customs, but this has nothing to do with whether the transaction can be profitable. You can understand that this is the foundation of career success, yes, but it is only a necessary and sufficient condition. Most excellent traders are "good people", but "good people" are not necessarily profitable. "Blind bridge paving, murder and arson. I went to the Western Heaven to ask my Buddha, and the Buddha said, "I can't help it. "In short, it is to focus on what you have to do now and try your best to reach the upper limit of your ability. Other things, Buddha is helpless, can you be helpless? ...