The judicial appraisal determined that "there is an indirect causal relationship between the school's performance of educational management and the occurrence of this mental disorder." The difficulty in this case is how to assess the proportion of the school's indirect causal relationship in the liability.

The proud man who became a fund manager was investigated by his school because he was suspected of making two "illegal" remarks online. He suffered from schizophrenia as a result of the investigation.

The delusion suddenly started, but the school claimed that its behavior was not inappropriate; the forensic analysis concluded that there was an indirect causal relationship between the school's behavior and the student's mental disorder. This is where the question arises: who is responsible for the indirect causation?

What proportion of the judicial appraisal determined that "there is a direct causal relationship between the school's performance of educational management and the occurrence of this mental disorder"? The difficulty in the original case is how to assess how much of the school's indirect causal relationship accounts for the blame.

proportion.

Trainee reporter Ren Xue, reporter Du Xiao. Trainee You Yin first met Yang Hui (pseudonym) at his home. He was wearing a pair of white-rimmed glasses, his eyes were full of alertness, and he looked relaxed and dignified.

Standing with a slight cry on his face.

All the windows in his house are tightly closed. According to his parents, it is because Yang Hui is mentally stimulated and often hears voices, so he hardly goes out and is unwilling to open the doors or windows.

Yang Hui was originally a student at Beijing Ziwu University. He was suspected of posting two "illegal" messages online and was investigated several times by the school.

Within a year after being investigated, Yang Hui suffered from auditory hallucinations and was often monitored and supervised. Later, he was diagnosed with schizophrenia.

Yang Hui's parents believed that the school's compliance with the law and improper investigation methods had caused their son to suffer mental shock and induce mental illness, so they took the school to court.

The court rejected the plaintiff's confession in the first instance, but the defendant appealed. The current case is currently in the second instance.

The mother laughed and said that her son went "crazy" after being investigated by the school. The incident dates back to around New Year's Eve in 2007.

At that time, two seemingly illegal public opinions appeared on the campus network of Beijing Zizizi University. After investigation, it was found that the IP address of the speaker was the same as that of Yang Hui’s computer.

"Beginning in January 2007, I received a call from the school saying that my son had made a mistake at school and asked me to come back." Yang Hui's mother recalled that after she went there, the school's relevant leaders investigated Yang Hui on the matter, "

My son explained at the time that the online posts were not made by himself, and his classmates often used his computer to access the Internet, and many classmates had keys to the dormitory. " Yang Hui's mother said that the school asked Yang Hui not to go home or leave this weekend.

In school, he must write written information, and he is required to have his mobile phone switched on at all times and be on call for assigned inspections.

Later, Yang’s mother spoke to reporters and played a video of the school’s investigation into the matter.

"I don't want to see this!" Yang Hui protested loudly. He returned to our roof and closed the door.

This nearly 15-minute video was recorded in an office.

In addition to Yang Hui, the face of a woman who was interrogating him also appeared on the screen.

There is also a man's voice on the painted dot.

The video shows that Yang Hui was extremely nervous at the time, with his hands rubbing each other non-stop.

According to Yang Hui's mother, the school later threatened that Yang Hui would not be able to take the graduation exam if he did not tell who received the post.

A few weeks later, when Yang Hui returned home, his emotions were high and he remained silent.

"At the beginning of April, Yang Hui started day school. I welcome him to school every day." Yang Hui's father told reporters.

According to Yang Hui’s mother, in July 2007, Yang Hui began to have relatively severe auditory hallucinations and fantasies. “He felt that I was following him. One time, he actually told a stranger when he was picking up his mother-in-law in the car that he was being followed.

of".

In addition, Yang Hui thought that there were cameras installed in his home and his every move was being monitored.

"In November 2007, he once had a meal and dropped the plates and bowls without any warning. After that, he often dropped things. He also dropped the TV and computer at home." Yang Hui's mother said, and then Yang Hui

His condition got worse and improved, and he lost consciousness of his parents for a while.

"One time when I came home, he pulled me to the door and said that I was sent back to supervise him in collusion with their school." Mother Yang's eyes turned red when she said this.

Yang's father said that during that time, he was attacked almost every day.

At first, Er Cheng couldn't bear it any longer. In tears, he called the police and sent his son back to a mental hospital.

In January 2008, Yang Hui was sent to Beiyuan Psychiatric Hospital for hospitalization and was diagnosed with schizophrenia. After admission, he went to the Hospice Hospital and was diagnosed with paranoid psychosis.

“My son used to be a very obedient child, he never caused trouble and was very sensible.