In October 1924, the second direct war broke out.

General Feng Yuxiang, as the commander-in-chief of the Third Army of the Zhili Party, took advantage of the fact that the two armies were imprisoned in Shimen Village and Shanhaiguan to accept a bribe of 500,000 silver dollars from Zhang Xueliang.

He secretly led his troops back to Beijing, imprisoned President Cao Kun, overthrew the government directly under Cao Kun, and expelled the abandoned emperor Puyi from the palace.

Feng Yuxiang imprisoned the president, caused chaos, and overthrew the regime by force. He is not worthy of recognition.

However, Feng Yuxiang's expulsion of Puyi from the Forbidden City has long been controversial.

Some people say that if Feng Yuxiang hadn't driven Puyi out of the palace, China might have had a spiritual leader who acted as an anchor on the sea like the United Kingdom. China wouldn't have had so many thieves, it wouldn't have been on the track of democracy and the rule of law, and there wouldn't have been

Endless war.

Moreover, the biggest consequence of Puyi being driven out of the Forbidden City was to surrender to the enemy, willingly become a puppet of the Japanese, and run to the Northeast to establish the anti-people puppet Manchukuo.

He also said that the situations between China and the UK cannot be compared and there is no comparability.

Feng Yuxiang was right to drive Puyi out of the palace.

So let's take a look, what is Feng Yuxiang's reason for driving Pu Yi away?

The "Conditions for Preferential Treatment of the Qing Dynasty" stipulates: "After the emperor resigns, he will move to a newly built place outside the Forbidden City to live permanently. Those who take care of the royal family will be retained as usual, and no new eunuchs or maids will be recruited."

"It can be seen that the Forbidden City is only a temporary residence, and there are regulations for Puyi's leaving the palace. The revised regulations did not deprive Puyi of his freedom. Article 3 of the preferential treatment conditions says: If you move out of the palace on the same day, you can freely choose to live in the future. However, during the Republic of China

The government still has the responsibility to protect. Feng Yuxiang's breach of contract was to abolish the title of Emperor Xuantong and reduce the 4 million yuan allocated by the special fund of the Communist Party of China after the resignation of the emperor in the original regulations to 50.

Ten thousand yuan, reduced by one-eighth, but Feng Yuxiang did this because Puyi breached the contract first, and the "Qing Dynasty Preferential Treatment Conditions" clearly stipulated that the emperor agreed with the political system. But of course, Puyi ascended the throne again with the support of the commander-in-chief Zhang Xun.

Puyi was only 12 years old at the time, an ignorant child with no capacity for civil conduct. But as long as the title of Emperor Puyi is still there, the old officials of the Qing Dynasty will die with ulterior motives, and they will come back to life and stage the scandal of restoration. Even if Puyi arrives in Tianjin, the warlord Zhang will be killed.

Kang Youwei and Wang Shizhen gathered around Puyi and dreamed of restoration, which showed that Puyi's appeal was too great (Zhang had been providing funds for Puyi during this period). Therefore, only by abolishing the imperial title and driving him out of the palace would those people be allowed to go.

It is indeed a bit unkind for Feng Yuxiang to reduce expenses for Pu Yi, but it can also be thought that this is to prevent Pu Yi from spending so much money, misbehaving and recruiting rebellion. Feng Yuxiang must be the one to drive Pu Yi out.

His own selfish motives, such as gaining fame and selling cultural relics from the Forbidden City to increase his salary, are the consequences. Then, firstly, Puyi will be punished for breach of contract, and secondly, depriving Puyi of his title and driving him out of the palace will break the restorers.

Moreover, the Qing Dynasty was ruled by ethnic minorities and had lost its legitimacy. The slogan of the Revolution of 1911 was "Drive out the Tatars and restore China." The success of the Revolution of 1911 was because the only supporters of the Qing Dynasty were Zhang Zuolin and Zhang Zuolin.

The social elites such as Zhang Xun and Kang Youwei despised and hated the Qing Dynasty. Even if Feng Yuxiang did not revise the treaty, Puyi would not be able to play the role of the Japanese emperor and the British royal family. There was no direct connection between Puyi's surrender and this incident.

Cause and effect, because Puyi was unwilling, unconvinced, and always wanted to redeem himself, so he would be a puppet of the Japanese. In his opinion, imperial power was more important than anything else. At that time, Lu Xun's annual salary was only 4,000 yuan, and he earned 40,000 yuan in 2014.

Dayang. But this was already a high salary during the Republic of China, which was equivalent to one million yuan per year. During the Republic of China, the fee paid to Puyi was 120 million yuan, which was a well-off life. He thought.

While sleeping and dreaming, he had to walk on the wooden bridge of betrayal. He should not let Feng Yuxiang take the blame. Moreover, after learning that Pu Yi had contacted the Japanese spy leader Doihara Shoko, Chiang Kai-shek sent an old minister of the Qing Dynasty.

Gao Youtang stayed and conveyed the sincerity of the National Government: as long as Puyi did not go to the Northeast, he could go back to live in Shanghai or even Hong Kong. Chiang Kai-shek was willing to restore the "Qing Dynasty Preferential Treatment Conditions" and Emperor Puyi would pay the preferential treatment fee every year.

Rest assured, you can pay a huge sum of money in one go or have it guaranteed by a foreign bank.

However, Puyi is determined to save it. Even if he is the father, it is not the fault of others.